Bill Text: NY S02947 | 2023-2024 | General Assembly | Introduced


Bill Title: Enacts the "childhood lead poisoning prevention and safe housing act of 2023"; requires the reduction and elimination of lead-based paint hazards; defines terms; provides that properties shall be maintained free of conditions conducive to lead paint poisoning.

Spectrum: Partisan Bill (Democrat 11-0)

Status: (Introduced) 2024-01-03 - REFERRED TO JUDICIARY [S02947 Detail]

Download: New_York-2023-S02947-Introduced.html



                STATE OF NEW YORK
        ________________________________________________________________________

                                          2947

                               2023-2024 Regular Sessions

                    IN SENATE

                                    January 26, 2023
                                       ___________

        Introduced  by  Sens.  KAVANAGH, BAILEY, BRESLIN, CLEARE, HOYLMAN-SIGAL,
          MAY, PARKER, RIVERA, SALAZAR, SEPULVEDA  --  read  twice  and  ordered
          printed,  and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Judici-
          ary

        AN ACT to amend the real property law, the labor law, the tax  law,  the
          state  finance  law, the multiple dwelling law, the multiple residence
          law, the social services law and the public health law, in relation to
          enacting the "childhood lead poisoning prevention and safe housing act
          of 2023"

          The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and  Assem-
        bly, do enact as follows:

     1    Section  1. This act shall be known and may be cited as the "childhood
     2  lead poisoning prevention and safe housing act of 2023".
     3    § 2. Legislative findings and purposes. 1. (a) Lead poisoning of chil-
     4  dren persists as one of the most prevalent and preventable environmental
     5  diseases in New York. Nearly 100,000 children were newly identified with
     6  levels of lead in their blood at or above  5  micrograms  per  deciliter
     7  (ug/dL)  in  New  York state between 2011 and 2015. Moreover, only about
     8  one-third of  children  are  receiving  the  lead  screenings  that  are
     9  required by law and therefore, the actual number of children affected by
    10  the ingestion or inhalation of lead is undoubtedly significantly greater
    11  than  reported. Prevention is the only effective way to protect children
    12  from irreversible damage. Unless lead poisoning is  prevented,  elevated
    13  blood  lead  levels will result in impairment of the ability of children
    14  to think, concentrate, and learn.
    15    (b) Medical research indicates that  children  can  suffer  permanent,
    16  irreparable  damage  at  blood  levels  even lower than 5ug/dL, and that
    17  there is no level of lead  ingestion  or  inhalation  which  is  without
    18  adverse impact. Medical research also indicates that fetal injuries from
    19  lead paint can occur if women have elevated blood levels during pregnan-
    20  cy.    Because  of  this, intervention measures that wait until children

         EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
                              [ ] is old law to be omitted.
                                                                   LBD07256-01-3

        S. 2947                             2

     1  have been exposed have limited benefits,  and  the  pursuit  of  primary
     2  prevention,  which  means  eliminating  lead hazards before children are
     3  exposed, has been recommended by the federal centers for disease control
     4  and  prevention  (CDC) and promoted by leading experts in the field as a
     5  critical course of action to protect the health of young children.
     6    (c) Adult exposure to lead is also dangerous. It increases the risk of
     7  mortality from hypertension and cardiovascular  disease  with  a  recent
     8  large-scale  study  finding that 400,000 deaths per year in the U.S. are
     9  attributable to lead exposure. The study found  that  even  adult  blood
    10  lead concentrations lower than 5 ug/dL are associated with mortality. In
    11  addition,  the  federal environmental protection agency (EPA) classifies
    12  lead as a probable human carcinogen.
    13    (d) The predominant cause of lead poisoning in children is the  inges-
    14  tion or inhalation of lead particles from deteriorating or abraded lead-
    15  based paint from older and poorly maintained residences.
    16    (e) Deteriorating lead-based paint or excessive amounts of lead-conta-
    17  minated dust in these poorly maintained homes, or lead-contaminated soil
    18  around  residences, endangers the intellectual and emotional development
    19  and physical well-being of affected children, and  endangers  the  long-
    20  term  health of all inhabitants. In addition, unsafe work practices that
    21  inadequately control lead dust in the  repair  or  renovation  of  older
    22  homes can cause substantial lead hazards.
    23    (f)  Although  New  York  state  banned the sale of lead paint in 1970
    24  (chapter 338 of the laws of 1970), seventy percent of New York's housing
    25  stock was constructed prior  to  1970,  and  seventy-eight  percent  was
    26  constructed  prior to 1978, the year federal law banned the use of lead-
    27  based paint in residential homes. At least ninety percent of  lead-based
    28  paint  still  remaining in occupied housing exists in units built before
    29  1960. New York state has both the largest  percentage  and  the  largest
    30  absolute number of older housing units with lead paint in the nation.
    31    (g)  The  dangers  posed  by  lead-based  paint  can  be substantially
    32  reduced, although not eliminated, by taking measures  to  prevent  paint
    33  deterioration  and  limiting children's exposure to paint chips and lead
    34  dust.
    35    (h) The deterioration of lead-based paint in older residences  results
    36  in increased expenses each year for the state of New York in the form of
    37  special  education  and  other education expenses, medical care for lead
    38  poisoned children, and expenditures  for  delinquent  youth  and  others
    39  needing  special supervision. The overall social costs of lead poisoning
    40  are estimated to amount to at least six billion dollars annually.
    41    (i) Older housing units remain an important part of New York's housing
    42  stock, particularly for those of modest or limited incomes. The  problem
    43  of  lead-based paint in housing, as well as in surrounding soil, affects
    44  urban, suburban and rural areas of the state.
    45    (j) The existing housing codes and enforcement  systems  in  most  New
    46  York  jurisdictions  do not include primary prevention measures for lead
    47  hazards and have proven ineffective in encouraging widespread lead-based
    48  paint hazard abatement, mitigation, and control. As a  result,  in  many
    49  cases  lead  hazards  are often not identified until a child is found to
    50  have high concentrations of lead in their blood.
    51    (k) The financial incentives currently in place have not proven suffi-
    52  cient to motivate landlords and other property owners to undertake wide-
    53  spread and effective lead-based paint hazard abatement, mitigation,  and
    54  control;  moreover  low and moderate income property owners may not have
    55  access to the  resources  to  eliminate  or  substantially  reduce  lead
    56  hazards.

        S. 2947                             3

     1    (l)  Insurance companies are reluctant to provide coverage to property
     2  owners in the absence of evidence that lead hazards have been  appropri-
     3  ately addressed.
     4    (m)  Knowledge of lead-based paint hazards, their control, mitigation,
     5  abatement, and risk avoidance is not sufficiently widespread, especially
     6  outside urban areas.
     7    2. The purposes of this act are:
     8    (a) to increase the supply of affordable rental housing in  the  state
     9  of  New  York in which measures have been taken to eliminate or substan-
    10  tially reduce the risk of childhood lead poisoning;
    11    (b) to ensure that New York's response  to  lead-based  paint  hazards
    12  focuses  on primary prevention as the essential tool to combat childhood
    13  lead poisoning - meaning that lead hazards are  eliminated  or  substan-
    14  tially  reduced  before  a child has been poisoned, and thus to substan-
    15  tially reduce, and eventually eliminate, the incidence of childhood lead
    16  poisoning in the state of New York;
    17    (c) to establish lead hazard control standards in  the  state  of  New
    18  York, and make their enforcement more certain and more effective;
    19    (d)  to  improve  public  awareness of the dangers of exposure to lead
    20  even at low levels, and to educate  both  property  owners  and  tenants
    21  about practices that can reduce the incidence of lead poisoning; and
    22    (e)  to  provide resources for property owners who commit to undertake
    23  specified lead hazard reduction measures;
    24    (f) to improve the responses of the  department  of  health  in  those
    25  situations  where  children  are  identified  with  elevated  blood lead
    26  levels; and
    27    (g) to better coordinate across various departments  and  agencies  to
    28  protect children from lead poisoning.
    29    §  3.  The  real property law is amended by adding a new article 19 to
    30  read as follows:
    31                                 ARTICLE 19
    32            CHILDHOOD LEAD POISONING PREVENTION AND SAFE HOUSING
    33  Section 500. Definitions.
    34          501. Requirements for owners of affected properties.
    35          502. Investigation and inspection of affected properties by  the
    36                 deputy commissioner.
    37          503. Safe  work  practices  for activities disturbing lead-based
    38                 paint or paint of unknown lead content in affected  prop-
    39                 erties.
    40          504. Accreditation  of  inspectors  and  contractors  performing
    41                 work.
    42          505. Enforcement.
    43          506. Injunctive relief.
    44          507. Retaliatory evictions prohibited.
    45          508. Lead poisoning prevention fee.
    46          509. Designation of exempt municipalities; minimum standards for
    47                 lead-based paint poisoning prevention programs.
    48          510. Reporting.
    49    § 500. Definitions. 1. "Abatement" means any set of measures  designed
    50  to  permanently  eliminate lead-based paint or lead-based paint hazards.
    51  Abatement includes the removal of lead-based paint, the permanent enclo-
    52  sure or encapsulation of lead-based paint, the replacement of components
    53  or fixtures painted with lead-based paint, and the removal or  permanent
    54  covering  of  soil-lead hazards. When abatement has occurred, a property
    55  is deemed abated.

        S. 2947                             4

     1    2. "Affected property" means a room or group of rooms within a proper-
     2  ty constructed before nineteen hundred seventy-eight that form a  single
     3  independent  habitable dwelling unit for occupation by one or more indi-
     4  viduals that has living facilities with permanent provisions for living,
     5  sleeping,  eating, cooking, and sanitation. "Affected property" does not
     6  include:
     7    (a) a unit within a hotel, motel, or  similar  seasonal  or  transient
     8  facility unless such unit is occupied by one or more persons for a peri-
     9  od exceeding thirty days;
    10    (b) an area which is secured and inaccessible to occupants;
    11    (c)  a  unit  which is not offered for rent or not incident to employ-
    12  ment;
    13    (d) an unoccupied dwelling unit or residential property that is to  be
    14  demolished,  provided  the dwelling unit or property will remain unoccu-
    15  pied until demolition;
    16    (e) a dwelling or dwelling unit within an exempt municipality; or
    17    (f) property owned or operated by a unit of federal, state,  or  local
    18  government,  or  any  public, quasi-public, or municipal corporation, if
    19  the property is subject to lead standards that are  equal  to,  or  more
    20  stringent  than, the requirements for lead-stabilized status under para-
    21  graph c of subdivision one of section five hundred one of this  article,
    22  but  does  include  privately-owned properties that receive governmental
    23  rental assistance.
    24    3. "Area of high risk" means an area designated as such by the  deputy
    25  commissioner,  pursuant  to section five hundred two of this article, in
    26  conjunction with the commissioner of health pursuant to section thirteen
    27  hundred seventy of the public health law.
    28    4. "Change in occupancy" means a change of tenant in an affected prop-
    29  erty in which the property is vacated and possession is  either  surren-
    30  dered to the owner or abandoned.
    31    5. "Chewable surface" shall mean a protruding interior windowsill in a
    32  dwelling  unit  in  an affected property that is readily accessible to a
    33  child under age seven. "Chewable surface" shall also mean any other type
    34  of interior edge or protrusion in a dwelling unit in an affected proper-
    35  ty, such as a rail or stair.
    36    6. "Condition conducive to lead poisoning"  means:  (a)  a  lead-based
    37  paint hazard; and/or (b) other environmental conditions which may result
    38  in significant lead exposure, including soil-lead hazards.
    39    7. "Containment" means the physical measures taken to ensure that dust
    40  and  debris created or released during lead-based paint hazard reduction
    41  are not spread, blown, or tracked from inside to outside  of  the  work-
    42  site.
    43    8.  "Deputy  commissioner" means such person as has been designated by
    44  the commissioner of housing and community renewal to enforce this  arti-
    45  cle.
    46    9.  "Deteriorated paint" means any interior or exterior paint or other
    47  coating that is curling, scaling, flaking,  blistering,  peeling,  chip-
    48  ping,  chalking,  cracking, or loose in any manner, such that a space or
    49  pocket of air is behind a portion thereof or such that the paint is  not
    50  completely adhered to the underlying subsurface, or is otherwise damaged
    51  or separated from the substrate.
    52    10. "Deteriorated subsurface" shall mean an unstable or unsound paint-
    53  ed  subsurface,  an indication of which can be observed through a visual
    54  inspection, including, but not limited to, rotted or  decayed  wood,  or
    55  wood or plaster that has been subject to moisture or disturbance.
    56    11. "Division" means the division of housing and community renewal.

        S. 2947                             5

     1    12.  "Dwelling"  means  a  building  or  structure or portion thereof,
     2  including the property occupied by and  appurtenant  to  such  dwelling,
     3  which is occupied in whole or in part as the home, residence or sleeping
     4  place  of one or more human beings and shall, without limiting the fore-
     5  going,  include  child care facilities for children under seven years of
     6  age, kindergartens and nursery schools.
     7    13. "Dwelling unit" means a:
     8    (a) single-family dwelling,  including  attached  structures  such  as
     9  porches and stoops; or
    10    (b)  housing  unit in a structure that contains more than one separate
    11  housing unit, and in which each  such  unit  is  used  or  occupied,  or
    12  intended  to  be  used  or occupied, in whole or in part, as the home or
    13  separate living quarters of one or more persons.
    14    14. "Encapsulation" means the application of  a  covering  or  coating
    15  that  acts as a barrier between the lead-based paint and the environment
    16  and that relies for its durability on adhesion between  the  encapsulant
    17  and  the  painted  surface,  and  on the integrity of the existing bonds
    18  between paint layers and between the paint and the substrate.   Encapsu-
    19  lation  may  be  used  as  a  method  of abatement if it is designed and
    20  performed so as to be permanent.
    21    15. "Exempt municipality" means the cities of New York, Rochester, and
    22  Syracuse, and such other municipalities that the commissioner of housing
    23  and community renewal may designate pursuant  to  section  five  hundred
    24  nine of this article.
    25    16. "Exterior surfaces" means:
    26    (a) all fences and porches that are part of a dwelling;
    27    (b)  all outside surfaces of a dwelling that are accessible to a child
    28  under the age of seven and that:
    29    (1) are attached to the outside of such dwelling; or
    30    (2) consist of other buildings that are appurtenant to such  dwelling,
    31  such as a garage or shed; and
    32    (c)  all  painted  surfaces  in  stairways,  hallways, entrance areas,
    33  recreation areas, laundry areas, and garages within a multifamily dwell-
    34  ing that are common to individual dwelling units, one or more  of  which
    35  constitutes an affected property.
    36    17.  "Friction  surface" means an interior or exterior painted surface
    37  that touches or is in contact with another surface, such  that  the  two
    38  surfaces are capable of relative motion and abrade, scrape, or bind when
    39  in  relative motion. Friction surfaces shall include, but not be limited
    40  to, window frames and jambs, doors, and hinges.
    41    18. "G" means gram, "mg" means milligram (thousandth of a  gram),  and
    42  "ug" means microgram (millionth of a gram).
    43    19.  "Hazard reduction" means measures designed to reduce or eliminate
    44  human exposure to lead-based paint hazards.
    45    20. "High-efficiency particle air vacuum"  or  "HEPA-vacuum"  means  a
    46  device capable of filtering out particles of 0.3 microns or greater from
    47  a  body  of  air  at  an  efficiency of 99.97% or greater; "HEPA-vacuum"
    48  includes use of a HEPA-vacuum.
    49    21. "Impact surface" means an interior  or  exterior  painted  surface
    50  that  shows  evidence, such as marking, denting, or chipping, that it is
    51  subject to damage by repeated sudden force, such  as  certain  parts  of
    52  door frames, moldings, or baseboards.
    53    22. "Inspection" means a comprehensive survey by a properly accredited
    54  person  to  determine  the  presence  of lead-based paint and lead-based
    55  paint hazards and the provision of a report explaining  the  results  of
    56  the inspection.

        S. 2947                             6

     1    23.  "Interior  windowsill"  means  a portion of the horizontal window
     2  ledge that is protruding into the interior of a room.
     3    24.  "Investigation" means an examination conducted by the owner of an
     4  affected property, the owner's agent or employee, or someone retained by
     5  the owner, in accordance with the requirements established by the deputy
     6  commissioner, to determine whether the affected property meets the stan-
     7  dards of lead-stabilized status as defined in paragraph c of subdivision
     8  one of section five hundred one of this article.
     9    25. "Lead-based paint" means paint or other  similar  surface  coating
    10  material  containing  0.5  milligrams  of  lead per square centimeter or
    11  greater, as determined by laboratory analysis, or by an  x-ray  fluores-
    12  cence  analyzer.  If  an  x-ray  fluorescence analyzer is used, readings
    13  shall be corrected for substrate bias when necessary as specified by the
    14  performance characteristic sheets released by the United States environ-
    15  mental protection agency (EPA) and the United States department of hous-
    16  ing and urban development (HUD)  for  the  specific  x-ray  fluorescence
    17  analyzer  used. X-ray fluorescence readings shall be classified as posi-
    18  tive, negative or inconclusive in accordance with the HUD guidelines for
    19  the evaluation and control of lead-based paint hazards in housing  (June
    20  1995,  revised  1997 and 2012) and the performance characteristic sheets
    21  released by the EPA and HUD for the specific x-ray fluorescence analyzer
    22  used. X-ray fluorescence readings  that  fall  within  the  inconclusive
    23  zone,  as  determined by the performance characteristic sheets, shall be
    24  confirmed by laboratory  analysis  of  paint  chips,  results  shall  be
    25  reported  in milligrams of lead per square centimeter and the measure of
    26  such laboratory analysis shall be definitive. If laboratory analysis  is
    27  used  to determine lead content, results shall be reported in milligrams
    28  of lead per square centimeter. Where the surface area of  a  paint  chip
    29  sample  cannot be accurately measured or if an accurately measured paint
    30  chip sample cannot be removed, a laboratory analysis may be reported  in
    31  percent  by weight.  In such case, lead-based paint shall mean any paint
    32  or other similar surface-coating material containing more than 0.25%  of
    33  metallic  lead,  based on the non-volatile content of the paint or other
    34  similar surface-coating material except that, if the EPA or a  successor
    35  agency,  or  the  HUD or a successor agency, adopts more stringent defi-
    36  nitions of lead-based paint, such more stringent levels shall apply  for
    37  the  purposes  of  this  article and the division shall update its regu-
    38  lations so they are at least as stringent as the federal  levels.  In  a
    39  residential  dwelling constructed before 1970, it shall be presumed that
    40  paint or other similar surface coating material contains 0.5  milligrams
    41  of  lead  per  square centimeter or greater unless it has been tested in
    42  the manner specified in this section by personnel qualified pursuant  to
    43  subdivision two of section five hundred four of this article.
    44    26. "Lead-based paint hazard" means any condition in, or proximate to,
    45  a  dwelling  or  dwelling  unit that may result in exposure to lead that
    46  could result in adverse human health effects from any of  the  following
    47  conditions:  lead-contaminated  dust;  lead-based  paint that is deteri-
    48  orated; lead-based paint that is present on chewable  surfaces,  deteri-
    49  orated  subsurfaces, friction surfaces, or impact surfaces; or soil-lead
    50  hazards.
    51    27. "Lead-contained" means property that has  attained  lead-contained
    52  property  status within the meaning of paragraph d of subdivision one of
    53  section five hundred one of this article.
    54    28. "Lead-contaminated dust" means surface dust that contains  a  mass
    55  per  area  concentration  of lead equal to or exceeding 5 micrograms per
    56  square foot ("ug/ft2") on floors, or 40 ug/ft2 on  interior  windowsills

        S. 2947                             7

     1  based  on  wipe  sample,  or 100 ug/ft2 on window wells, or 40 ug/ft2 on
     2  porch floors, or such more stringent standards as may be adopted by  the
     3  division  of  housing  and community renewal, except that, if the United
     4  States  environmental  protection  agency  or a successor agency, or the
     5  United States department of housing and urban development or a successor
     6  agency, adopts more stringent  definitions  of  lead-contaminated  dust,
     7  such more stringent levels shall apply for the purposes of this article,
     8  and  the  division  shall update its regulations so they are at least as
     9  stringent as the federal levels.
    10    29. "Lead-free" means property that has  attained  lead-free  property
    11  status  within  the meaning of paragraph e of subdivision one of section
    12  five hundred one of this article.
    13    30. "Lead-stabilized" means property that has attained lead-stabilized
    14  property status within the meaning of paragraph c of subdivision one  of
    15  section five hundred one of this article.
    16    31.  "Local  designee"  means  a  municipal, county, or other official
    17  designated by the deputy commissioner as responsible for  assisting  the
    18  designating  authority, relevant state agencies, and relevant county and
    19  municipal authorities, in implementing the activities specified by  this
    20  article for the localities.
    21    32.  "Occupant" means any individual living or sleeping in a building,
    22  or having possession of a space within a building.
    23    33. "Owner" means a person, firm, corporation, nonprofit organization,
    24  partnership, government, guardian, conservator, receiver, trustee, exec-
    25  utor, or other judicial officer, or other entity which,  alone  or  with
    26  others, owns, holds, or controls the freehold or leasehold title or part
    27  of  the  title to property, with or without actually possessing it. Such
    28  term includes a vendee who possesses the title, but does not  include  a
    29  mortgagee  or  an  owner  of a reversionary interest under a ground rent
    30  lease. "Owner" includes any authorized agent of the owner,  including  a
    31  property manager or leasing agent.
    32    34.  "Permanent"  means  an  expected  design  life of at least twenty
    33  years.
    34    35. "Person" means any natural person.
    35    36. "Relocation expenses" means all expenses necessitated by the relo-
    36  cation of a tenant's household to housing free of lead hazards,  includ-
    37  ing, but not limited to, moving and hauling expenses, the HEPA-vacuuming
    38  of  all upholstered furniture, laundering of clothes and linens, payment
    39  of a security deposit for the relocation housing, and  installation  and
    40  connection of utilities and appliances.
    41    37.  "Rent-to-own  contract" shall mean any agreement between an owner
    42  of real property and a tenant which provides that after a specified term
    43  the tenant will take ownership of the rented home.
    44    38. "Resides" shall mean to routinely spend ten or more hours per week
    45  within a dwelling unit.
    46    39. "Soil-lead hazard" means soil in a play area where  the  soil-lead
    47  concentration from a composite play area sample of bare soil is equal to
    48  or  greater  than 400 parts per million; or in the rest of the yard when
    49  the arithmetic mean lead  concentration  from  a  composite  sample  (or
    50  arithmetic  mean of composite samples) of bare soil from the rest of the
    51  yard (i.e., non-play areas) is equal to or greater than 1,200 parts  per
    52  million except that, if the United States environmental protection agen-
    53  cy or a successor agency, or the United States department of housing and
    54  urban  development  or  a  successor agency, adopts more stringent defi-
    55  nitions of soil-lead hazard, such more stringent levels shall apply  for

        S. 2947                             8

     1  the  purposes  of  this article, and the division shall update its regu-
     2  lations so they are at least as stringent as the federal levels.
     3    40.  "Tenant"  means  the  individual  named as the lessee in a lease,
     4  rental agreement, rent-to-own  contract,  or  other  form  of  occupancy
     5  agreement,  whether  written  or oral, for a dwelling unit, and includes
     6  tenancies incident to employment. Where applicable,  the  term  "tenant"
     7  shall also include any occupant of the tenant's household.
     8    41. "Wipe sample" means a sample collected by an appropriately accred-
     9  ited person wiping a representative surface of known area, as determined
    10  by  American Society for Testing Materials (ASTM) e1728 ("standard prac-
    11  tice for the field collection of settled dust samples using wipe  sampl-
    12  ing  methods for lead determination by atomic spectrometry techniques"),
    13  with lead determination conducted by an  accredited  laboratory  partic-
    14  ipating  in  the  environmental  lead  laboratory  accreditation program
    15  (NLAP).
    16    § 501. Requirements for owners of  affected  properties.  1.  Duty  to
    17  maintain affected properties. (a) All affected properties shall be main-
    18  tained free of conditions conducive to lead paint poisoning.
    19    (b) Within two years following the effective date of this section, all
    20  affected  properties shall be maintained as "lead-stabilized" as defined
    21  by paragraph (c) of this subdivision or "lead-contained" as  defined  by
    22  paragraph  (d)  of  this  subdivision, or "lead-free" as provided for in
    23  paragraph (e) of this subdivision.
    24    (c) An affected property will be considered  to  be  "lead-stabilized"
    25  when:
    26    (i)  All  exterior  and  interior  painted surfaces have been visually
    27  reviewed; and all chipping, peeling,  or  flaking  lead-based  paint  or
    28  paint  of unknown lead content on exterior and interior painted surfaces
    29  has been removed and repainted, or stabilized  and  repainted,  and  any
    30  structural defect that is causing or likely to cause lead-based paint or
    31  paint  of unknown lead content to chip, peel, or flake that the owner of
    32  the affected property has knowledge of, or with the exercise of  reason-
    33  able care should have knowledge of, has been repaired;
    34    (ii)  All  window  friction surfaces with lead-based paint or paint of
    35  unknown lead content have had such paint removed or permanently covered,
    36  such as via the installation of replacement window channels  or  slides,
    37  and  interior  window  troughs and windowsills have been either stripped
    38  and repainted, replaced, or encapsulated with vinyl, metal, or any other
    39  durable materials which render the surface smooth and cleanable;
    40    (iii) All doors and doorways have been adjusted or re-hung  as  neces-
    41  sary  to  prevent  the  rubbing  together of any surface with lead-based
    42  paint or paint of unknown lead content with another surface;
    43    (iv) All bare floors have been made smooth and cleanable;
    44    (v) All work has been completed in compliance with the safe work prac-
    45  tice regulations promulgated pursuant to section five hundred  three  of
    46  this article; and
    47    (vi) At the completion of any activities described in this subdivision
    48  that disturb lead-based paint or paint of unknown lead content:
    49    (A)  the  interior of the affected property has been HEPA vacuumed and
    50  washed with high phosphate detergent or its equivalent; and
    51    (B) clearance for lead-contaminated dust has been achieved  as  deter-
    52  mined  by  wipe  samples  in all areas accessible to occupants, taken by
    53  properly accredited independent personnel after completion of all activ-
    54  ities undertaken pursuant to paragraph (b) of this subdivision.
    55    (d) An affected property will be  considered  to  be  "lead-contained"
    56  when  a  certified  inspector,  accredited pursuant to the provisions of

        S. 2947                             9

     1  section five hundred four of this article, inspects the affected proper-
     2  ty and certifies that the affected property  has  been  tested  for  the
     3  presence  of  lead-based  paint and lead-contaminated dust in accordance
     4  with the standards and procedures established by regulations promulgated
     5  by the commissioner and states under penalties of perjury that:
     6    (i)  All  interior  surfaces  in  the  affected property either do not
     7  contain lead-based paint or have been permanently abated;
     8    (ii)(A) All exterior painted surfaces of the  affected  property  that
     9  were  chipping,  peeling,  or  flaking  have been restored with non-lead
    10  based paint and no exterior painted surfaces of  the  affected  property
    11  are chipping, peeling, or flaking; or
    12    (B)  All  exterior painted surfaces of the affected property have been
    13  covered with vinyl siding or similar siding and sealed in a manner  that
    14  prevents exposure to chipping, peeling, or flaking paint; and
    15    (iii)  Clearance for lead dust hazards has been achieved as determined
    16  by wipe samples in all areas accessible to occupants, taken by  properly
    17  accredited independent personnel.
    18    (e)  An  affected property will be considered to be "lead-free" when a
    19  certified inspector, accredited pursuant to the  provisions  of  section
    20  five  hundred  four  of this article, inspects the affected property and
    21  certifies that the affected property has been tested for the presence of
    22  lead-based paint and lead-contaminated dust in accordance with the stan-
    23  dards and procedures  established  by  regulations  promulgated  by  the
    24  commissioner  and  states  under  penalties  of perjury that there is no
    25  lead-based paint or  lead-contaminated  dust  present  on  the  interior
    26  surfaces  of  the  dwelling  unit,  no  lead-based paint on the interior
    27  surfaces of the common areas of the property, and  no  lead-based  paint
    28  present on any of the exterior surfaces of the property.
    29    2. Duty to inspect affected properties. (a) Unless an affected proper-
    30  ty  has been determined to be "lead-contained" or "lead-free" as defined
    31  in subdivision one of this section, the owner of such affected  property
    32  shall  cause an investigation to be made as provided in paragraph (b) of
    33  this subdivision, either directly by the owner,  the  owner's  agent  or
    34  employee,  or by any other person authorized by the deputy commissioner,
    35  to determine whether such property complies, at a minimum,  with  "lead-
    36  stabilized"  property  status.    Alternatively,  the owner may cause an
    37  inspection to be made by  a  person  trained  and  accredited  for  such
    38  inspections  as  described  in section five hundred four of this article
    39  for the purpose of determining whether the  affected  property  complies
    40  with  either  "lead-free"  property  status or "lead-contained" property
    41  status.
    42    (b) The investigation to ascertain whether a  property  complies  with
    43  "lead-stabilized"  property  status shall occur at least once a year and
    44  more often if necessary, such as when, in  the  exercise  of  reasonable
    45  care,  an  owner  knows or should know of a condition that is reasonably
    46  foreseeable to be conducive to  lead  poisoning,  or  when  an  occupant
    47  specifically  requests that an inspection or investigation be made based
    48  upon his or her reasonable belief that such a condition exists, or  when
    49  an  occupant  makes a complaint to the owner concerning a condition that
    50  the owner knows or should know is reasonably foreseeable to be conducive
    51  to lead poisoning.
    52    (c) In addition to any investigations or  inspections  required  under
    53  paragraph  (b) of this subdivision, the owner shall cause such an inves-
    54  tigation or inspection to be made within the thirty days  prior  to  the
    55  leasing,  rental,  or  other turnover of an affected property, and shall
    56  report the findings of that investigation or inspection  to  prospective

        S. 2947                            10

     1  tenants  in  accordance  with section 42 U.S.C. 4852d, 24 C.F.R. part 35
     2  subpart a and 40 C.F.R. part 40 subpart f or such successor  regulations
     3  and this article.
     4    3.  Duty  to maintain and provide records of compliance, and notice to
     5  occupants of affected properties.
     6    (a) Beginning two years following the effective date of this  section,
     7  owners of affected properties shall submit to the deputy commissioner or
     8  the  deputy  commissioner's  designee for the jurisdiction in which such
     9  property is located a certification of compliance with paragraph (b)  of
    10  subdivision  one  of  this section, in the manner directed by the deputy
    11  commissioner. Said certifications shall include the results of any  lead
    12  dust wipe tests, any tests for the presence of lead-based paint, and any
    13  inspections   conducted   by   inspectors  accredited  pursuant  to  the
    14  provisions of section five hundred nine of this article.  Certifications
    15  of affected properties as "lead stabilized" within the meaning of  para-
    16  graph  (c)  of  subdivision one of this section shall be submitted every
    17  three years. Certifications of affected properties as  "lead  contained"
    18  within  the  meaning of paragraph (d) of subdivision one of this section
    19  shall be submitted every ten years, unless clause  (B)  of  subparagraph
    20  (i)  of  paragraph  (d) of such subdivision has been completed, in which
    21  case such certification shall be submitted every twenty years.
    22    (b) When an owner of an affected property submits a  certification  to
    23  the  division  pursuant  to paragraph (a) of this subdivision, the owner
    24  shall also provide a copy of the certification and any  dust  wipe  test
    25  results  to  the  tenants  within  one month thereafter of providing the
    26  certification to the department or, for dwelling units that  are  vacant
    27  at the time of such certification, at the time tenants take occupancy.
    28    (c)  The  division  shall maintain a searchable public database of all
    29  certifications filed pursuant to this subdivision.
    30    (d) The owner of an affected property shall make and maintain a record
    31  of all investigations or inspections conducted under subdivision two  of
    32  this  section in a form prescribed by the deputy commissioner. The owner
    33  shall maintain such record, in electronic or  hard-copy  format,  for  a
    34  period  of ten years. Copies of such record shall be made available upon
    35  request to the deputy commissioner, his or her local  designee,  tenants
    36  and  occupants  of the affected property, and any prospective tenants or
    37  occupants of the affected property.
    38    (e) The owner shall cause a summary  of  inspections  conducted  under
    39  subdivision  two  of  this  section,  in a form prescribed by the deputy
    40  commissioner, to be conspicuously posted in a common area of the  dwell-
    41  ing  in or adjacent to main entrances. In cases where it is not feasible
    42  to post such reports in a common area, the owner or agent shall  deliver
    43  individual  copies  of  such summary to each affected unit. Said summary
    44  shall indicate that the full report of such investigation or  inspection
    45  is available to tenants upon request.
    46    (f)  All  leases offered to tenants or prospective tenants in affected
    47  properties shall contain a  notice,  conspicuously  set  forth  therein,
    48  which  advises  tenants  of the obligations of the owner as set forth in
    49  this section. Such notice shall be in a manner approved  by  the  deputy
    50  commissioner,  the  content  of which shall, at a minimum, be in English
    51  and Spanish.
    52    (g) Unless an affected property has been  certified  as  being  "lead-
    53  free,"  as provided in paragraph (e) of subdivision one of this section,
    54  any written or printed lease for the lease or  renting  of  an  affected
    55  property for a term beginning at a date more than one year following the
    56  effective  date  of this article shall include the following provisions,

        S. 2947                            11

     1  in both English and Spanish, in prominently displayed and  easily  read-
     2  able  type  or  printing:  "This property, constructed before January 1,
     3  1970, may contain lead-based paint. Lead-based paint, if it is not prop-
     4  erly  removed  or  maintained,  may  cause brain damage or other serious
     5  health impacts in children less than seven years of age and fetal injury
     6  in pregnant women. New York state law requires the  landlord  to  comply
     7  with  maintenance  standards  to  avoid lead-based paint hazards.   This
     8  property (owner or agent to check appropriate box):
     9    has been inspected by an independent  inspector  certified  under  New
    10  York state law within the past sixty days and found not to contain lead-
    11  based paint hazards.
    12    has  been  investigated by the owner, manager, or his/her agent within
    13  the past thirty days and observable lead-based paint hazards  have  been
    14  stabilized.
    15    has not been inspected for lead-based paint hazards. This property may
    16  contain  lead-based  paint  hazards dangerous to a child less than seven
    17  years of age."
    18    (h) At the time of the lease or renting of an affected property  with-
    19  out  a  written  or printed lease at a date more than one year following
    20  the effective date of this section, the front entranceway or door of the
    21  affected property shall be posted with a sign  containing  the  language
    22  quoted  in  paragraph  (f) of this subdivision and, if applicable, para-
    23  graph (g) of this subdivision, in both English and Spanish,  and  promi-
    24  nently displayed and in easily readable type or printing.
    25    §  502.  Investigation  and  inspection  of affected properties by the
    26  deputy commissioner. 1. (a) Beginning two years after the effective date
    27  of this section, the deputy commissioner or his or her designee for  the
    28  jurisdiction in which such property is located shall order an inspection
    29  of  an  affected  property  by  an  inspector accredited pursuant to the
    30  provisions of section five hundred four of this article, at the  expense
    31  of  the  owner of the affected property, whenever the deputy commission-
    32  er's designee for the jurisdiction in which  such  property  is  located
    33  receives  notification  that  the  affected property does not reasonably
    34  appear to comply with either the lead-free, lead-contained, or lead-sta-
    35  bilized property status.
    36    (b) Any state or local agency employees who have occasion  to  observe
    37  deteriorated  paint  or  any other condition believed to be conducive to
    38  lead poisoning at an affected property are  authorized  to  report,  and
    39  shall report, such conditions to the deputy commissioner's designee, and
    40  in  such  instance,  the deputy commissioner's designee shall require an
    41  inspection to be made of the affected property.
    42    (c) Beginning two years after the effective date of this section,  the
    43  deputy  commissioner  shall  establish  a  central  complaint system for
    44  tenants in affected properties to report deteriorated paint or any other
    45  condition believed to be conducive to  lead  poisoning  at  an  affected
    46  property, and in such instance, the deputy commissioner's designee shall
    47  require an inspection to be made of the affected property.
    48    (d)  An  inspection required under this subdivision shall be completed
    49  within ninety days  after  notification  of  the  deputy  commissioner's
    50  designee  for the jurisdiction in which such property is located. In the
    51  event such inspection results in a finding of lead hazards, a report  of
    52  such findings shall be immediately transmitted by the deputy commission-
    53  er  or  the deputy commissioner's designee for the jurisdiction in which
    54  such property is  located  to  the  appropriate  local  social  services
    55  department  pursuant  to section one hundred forty-three-b of the social
    56  services law.

        S. 2947                            12

     1    (e) Beginning two years after the effective date of this section,  the
     2  deputy  commissioner  shall  establish  and  maintain  an index and file
     3  containing all notifications or complaints of affected  properties  that
     4  may  not comply with the requirements of subdivision one of section five
     5  hundred  one  of  this  article and the results of inspections conducted
     6  pursuant to paragraph (d) of this subdivision. Said index and file shall
     7  be made publicly available in an accessible, electronic searchable  form
     8  on  a  website  maintained  by  the  division  of  housing and community
     9  renewal.
    10    2. An owner of an affected property at any time  after  the  effective
    11  date  of  this  section, may request voluntarily that the deputy commis-
    12  sioner, or the deputy commissioner's designee for  the  jurisdiction  in
    13  which  such  property  is located, conduct an inspection by an inspector
    14  accredited pursuant to the provisions of section five  hundred  four  of
    15  this  article,  of an affected property, at the expense of the owner, to
    16  determine whether it complies with the requirements for lead-free, lead-
    17  contained, or lead-stabilized property status. Such inspection shall  be
    18  completed within thirty days after the owner's request.
    19    3.  The  deputy  commissioner shall establish, in conjunction with the
    20  commissioner of health or her or  his  designee,  a  primary  prevention
    21  inspection program in areas of high risk to identify and target affected
    22  properties  where  there  are  persons  who may be exposed to lead-based
    23  paint hazards in order that inspections may  be  conducted  without  the
    24  receipt of a complaint or other such event triggering an inspection, and
    25  require  for each such area of high risk that the county commissioner of
    26  health or his or her other local  designee,  and  such  local  municipal
    27  building  or  property  maintenance  code  enforcement  officials having
    28  jurisdiction over such area as the deputy commissioner shall  designate,
    29  prepare and implement a strategy to:
    30    (a)  assure that a sufficient number of qualified inspection personnel
    31  are available;
    32    (b) identify the affected  properties  in  that  municipality,  census
    33  tract  or  census block group that are most likely to contain conditions
    34  conducive to lead poisoning;
    35    (c) require, at the owner's expense, the inspection of affected  prop-
    36  erties for conditions conducive to lead poisoning; and
    37    (d) require that such inspected properties attain lead-free, lead-con-
    38  tained,  or  lead-stabilized  status,  and elimination of all conditions
    39  conducive to lead poisoning in such properties,  using  lead  safe  work
    40  practices in accordance with the provisions of this article within thir-
    41  ty  days.  In preparing this primary prevention inspection strategy, the
    42  responsible officials shall, among other factors,  consider  reports  of
    43  persons  with  elevated  blood lead levels in other units in a building;
    44  the age and maintenance history of a building; and any available data on
    45  the presence of young children from birth  certificates  issued  by  the
    46  department of health.
    47    4.  An  inspector  shall submit a verified report of the result of the
    48  inspection conducted pursuant to subdivision one, two, or three of  this
    49  section to the deputy commissioner or the deputy commissioner's designee
    50  for  the  jurisdiction in which such property is located, the owner, and
    51  the tenant, if any, of the  affected  property.  Such  report  shall  be
    52  completed  subject  to penalties for perjury and include the inspector's
    53  state registration number and date  of  certification  to  perform  such
    54  inspections.  In the event such inspection results in a finding of lead-
    55  based paint hazards or conditions conducive to lead poisoning, a  report
    56  of such findings shall be promptly transmitted by the deputy commission-

        S. 2947                            13

     1  er  or  the deputy commissioner's designee for the jurisdiction in which
     2  such property is located and to the appropriate  local  social  services
     3  department  pursuant  to section one hundred forty-three-b of the social
     4  services law.
     5    §  503. Safe work practices for activities disturbing lead-based paint
     6  or paint of unknown lead content in affected  properties.  1.  All  work
     7  performed  by an owner or the owner's agents or contractors, in affected
     8  property, that disturbs lead-based paint or paint of  undetermined  lead
     9  content  shall  be  performed  in  accordance with safe work regulations
    10  promulgated by the commissioner of housing and community  renewal.  Such
    11  regulations shall provide for, among other things:
    12    (a) notice to tenants;
    13    (b)  training  requirements,  which  shall  require  that such work be
    14  performed by persons who have, at a minimum,  successfully  completed  a
    15  course  on  lead-safe  work practices given by or on behalf of the divi-
    16  sion, the department  of  labor,  by  the  United  States  environmental
    17  protection  agency or an entity authorized by it to give such course, or
    18  by the United States department of housing and urban development  or  an
    19  entity authorized by it to give such course;
    20    (c) precautions to prevent entry into the work area by occupants until
    21  clean-up is completed and for temporary relocation provided by the owner
    22  for  the occupants of a dwelling or dwelling unit to appropriate housing
    23  when work cannot be performed safely;
    24    (d) precautions to prevent the dispersion  of  lead  dust  and  debris
    25  during the work;
    26    (e) prohibited practices of lead paint removal, including dry scraping
    27  and  sanding,  use of power tools without proper environmental controls,
    28  and the use of toxic substances;
    29    (f) proper daily and final clean-up requirements;
    30    (g) dust wipe clearance testing;
    31    (h) pre-notification of local municipal code enforcement  agencies  or
    32  health departments, where appropriate; and
    33    (i)  exceptions  for  small jobs that involve disturbing less than two
    34  square feet of lead-based paint or paint of undetermined lead content or
    35  less than ten percent of the total surface area of peeling  paint  on  a
    36  type  of  component  with  a small surface area, such as a windowsill or
    37  door frame.
    38    2. A tenant shall, at reasonable times and upon appropriate notice  of
    39  not less than forty-eight hours, allow access to an affected property to
    40  the owner to perform any work required under this article.
    41    3.  If a tenant must vacate an affected property for a period of twen-
    42  ty-four hours or more in order to allow an owner to  perform  work  that
    43  will  disturb the paint on interior surfaces, the owner shall pay to the
    44  tenant in advance the reasonable relocation  expenses  that  the  tenant
    45  incurs directly related to the required relocation.
    46    4.  The  deputy  commissioner  or  the deputy commissioner's designee,
    47  within one hundred twenty days following  the  effective  date  of  this
    48  article,  shall establish guidelines and a trainer's manual for a "lead-
    49  safe housing awareness seminar" with a total class time of  three  hours
    50  or  less.  Such guidelines and materials shall be made available so that
    51  such courses may be offered by professional associations  and  community
    52  organizations  with a training capacity, existing accredited educational
    53  institutions, and for-profit educational providers.  All  such  offering
    54  proposals  shall  be reviewed and approved, based on seminar content and
    55  qualifications of instructors, by the deputy commissioner or the  deputy
    56  commissioner's designee.

        S. 2947                            14

     1    § 504. Accreditation of inspectors and contractors performing work. 1.
     2  No  person  shall  act as a contractor or supervisor to perform the work
     3  necessary for lead-based paint hazard abatement as defined in this arti-
     4  cle unless that person is accredited pursuant to one of the following:
     5    (a)  regulations  adopted  by  the  commissioner  of labor pursuant to
     6  section nine hundred forty-nine-b of the labor law governing the accred-
     7  itation of individuals to engage in lead-based paint activities;
     8    (b) certification by the United States environmental protection agency
     9  to engage in lead-based paint activities pursuant to 40  C.F.R.  745.226
    10  or successor regulation; or
    11    (c)  certification  by  a  state  or  tribal program authorized by the
    12  United States environmental protection  agency  to  certify  individuals
    13  engaged  in lead-based paint activities pursuant to 40 C.F.R. 745.325 or
    14  successor regulation.
    15    The commissioner of housing and  community  renewal  shall,  by  regu-
    16  lation, create exceptions to the accreditation requirement for instances
    17  where  the disturbance of lead-based paint is small and incidental, such
    18  as work that disturbs surfaces of less than either two  square  feet  of
    19  peeling  lead-based  paint  per room or ten percent of the total surface
    20  area of peeling paint on a type of component with a small surface  area,
    21  such as a windowsill or door frame.
    22    2.  No  person  shall  conduct  an inspection required by section five
    23  hundred one of this article, unless that person is  accredited  pursuant
    24  to one of the following:
    25    (a)  regulations  adopted  by  the  commissioner  of labor pursuant to
    26  section nine hundred forty-nine-b of the labor law governing the accred-
    27  itation of individuals to engage in lead-based paint activities; or
    28    (b) certification to conduct inspections by the United States environ-
    29  mental protection agency pursuant to 40 C.F.R. 745.226(b)  or  successor
    30  regulation; or
    31    (c)  certification  by  a  state  or  tribal program authorized by the
    32  United States environmental protection  agency  to  certify  individuals
    33  engaged  in lead-based paint activities pursuant to 40 C.F.R. 745.325 or
    34  successor regulation.
    35    3. All persons engaged in conducting inspections or  lead-based  paint
    36  hazard  abatement  work  under  this section shall secure, maintain, and
    37  file with the deputy commissioner proof of a  certificate  of  liability
    38  coverage,  which terms and conditions shall be determined by the commis-
    39  sioner of housing and community renewal.
    40    4. Any violation of the provisions of this section shall be  a  misde-
    41  meanor.
    42    §  505. Enforcement. 1. (a) Whenever the deputy commissioner or deputy
    43  commissioner's designee finds an affected property to not be in  compli-
    44  ance with the applicable requirements for either lead-free, or lead-con-
    45  tained,  or  lead-stabilized property status, the deputy commissioner or
    46  deputy commissioner's designee shall give  written  notice  and  demand,
    47  served as provided in this section, for the discontinuance of any condi-
    48  tion  failing  to  comply  with either the lead-free, lead-contained, or
    49  lead-stabilized standards in an affected  property  within  a  specified
    50  period  of  time  not  to exceed thirty days. The deputy commissioner or
    51  deputy commissioner's designee shall also immediately notify the  appro-
    52  priate  local social services department of the issuance of such written
    53  notice and demand pursuant to section one hundred forty-three-b  of  the
    54  social services law.
    55    (b)  The deputy commissioner shall establish and maintain an index and
    56  file containing all notices and demands issued pursuant to this section.

        S. 2947                            15

     1  Said index and file shall be made publicly available in  an  accessible,
     2  electronic  searchable  form  on a website maintained by the division of
     3  housing and community renewal.
     4    2.  In  the  event  of failure to comply with a notice and demand, the
     5  deputy commissioner or the deputy commissioner's designee shall  conduct
     6  a  formal  hearing  upon due notice in accordance with the provisions of
     7  this section and on proof of violation of such notice and  demand  shall
     8  order  the  owner  of  an affected property to take specified corrective
     9  actions to have the affected property satisfy  the  requirements,  at  a
    10  minimum,  of lead-contained or lead-stabilized property and may assess a
    11  penalty not to  exceed  two  thousand  five  hundred  dollars  for  each
    12  affected property. In the event of the continued failure to comply after
    13  the  expiration  of  thirty  days  from  the issuance of an order and/or
    14  penalty pursuant to this subdivision, the  deputy  commissioner  or  the
    15  deputy  commissioner's  designee shall cause the condition to be remedi-
    16  ated within the next thirty days, and may place a lien on such  property
    17  and  commence  such  legal  actions as are necessary to recover from the
    18  owner  of  such  property  the  deputy  commissioner's  expenditures  in
    19  connection therewith, including legal fees.
    20    3.  A  notice  required by this section may be served upon an owner or
    21  occupant of the dwelling or agent of the owner in the same manner  as  a
    22  summons  in  a civil action or by registered or certified mail to his or
    23  her last known address or place of residence.
    24    4. The deputy commissioner's designee having jurisdiction, county  and
    25  city  commissioners  of health, and local housing code enforcement agen-
    26  cies designated by the deputy commissioner's designee  having  jurisdic-
    27  tion  or  county  or  city  commissioner  of  health shall have the same
    28  authority, powers and duties within their  respective  jurisdictions  as
    29  has the deputy commissioner under the provisions of this article.
    30    5. The deputy commissioner or deputy commissioner's representative and
    31  an  official or agency specified in subdivision four of this section may
    32  request and shall receive from  all  public  officers,  departments  and
    33  agencies  of  the  state and its political subdivisions such cooperation
    34  and assistance as may be necessary or proper in the enforcement  of  the
    35  provisions of this article.
    36    6.  Any  violation  of the requirements of section five hundred one of
    37  this article shall also constitute a violation of any municipal or other
    38  local housing code and shall subject the owner of an  affected  property
    39  to all orders, criminal penalties, and other civil forfeitures or penal-
    40  ties  that  are possible under such municipal or local housing code. Any
    41  such violation shall also constitute a rent impairing  violation  within
    42  the  meaning of section three hundred two-a of the multiple dwelling law
    43  and section three hundred five-a of  the  multiple  residence  law,  and
    44  entitle  the  tenant  of  such dwelling to a rent rebate of no less than
    45  fifty percent or one thousand dollars per month, whichever  is  greater,
    46  or  such  greater  amount  as  a  court  of competent jurisdiction shall
    47  impose.
    48    7. Nothing contained in this article shall be construed  to  alter  or
    49  abridge  any  duties  and powers now or hereafter existing in the deputy
    50  commissioner, county boards of health, city and county commissioners  of
    51  health,  the New York city department of housing preservation and devel-
    52  opment and the department of health, local boards  of  health  or  other
    53  public agencies or public officials, or any private party, including the
    54  power to impose more stringent measures to protect public health.
    55    8.  The  office  of  the  attorney  general  and all local authorities
    56  responsible for the enforcement of state,  municipal,  and  other  local

        S. 2947                            16

     1  housing codes are hereby empowered to and shall vigorously enforce civil
     2  remedies  and/or  criminal  penalties provided for by law arising out of
     3  the failure to comply with the requirements of section five hundred  one
     4  or  section  five  hundred  four of this article and may seek injunctive
     5  relief where appropriate.
     6    9. Any administrative proceeding or civil or criminal action by  state
     7  or  local  officials  to enforce the provisions of this section shall be
     8  reported to the deputy commissioner.
     9    10. The removal of a tenant from or the surrender by the tenant  of  a
    10  dwelling  with  respect  to  which the deputy commissioner or his or her
    11  representative, pursuant to subdivision one of this section,  has  given
    12  written  notice  and demand for the discontinuance of a condition condu-
    13  cive to lead poisoning shall  not  absolve,  relieve  or  discharge  any
    14  persons  chargeable  therewith from the obligation and responsibility to
    15  discontinue such condition conducive to  lead  poisoning  in  accordance
    16  with the method of discontinuance prescribed therefor in such notice and
    17  demand.    For  the  purposes of this subdivision, "removal of a tenant"
    18  shall include vacate or condemnation orders.
    19    § 506. Injunctive relief. 1. If an owner of an affected property fails
    20  to comply with the requirements of section  five  hundred  one  or  five
    21  hundred  two  of this article, a tenant, an occupant or other interested
    22  persons may seek injunctive relief from a court of  competent  jurisdic-
    23  tion  against  the owner of the affected property in the form of a court
    24  order to compel compliance. For the purposes of this article, a court of
    25  competent jurisdiction shall include county court, city court,  district
    26  court, town court and village court.
    27    2.  In  any action or proceeding seeking injunctive relief pursuant to
    28  subdivision one of this section, either (a) the  visually  displayed  or
    29  (b)  the printed computerized files of the division, maintained pursuant
    30  to paragraph (b) of subdivision one of section five hundred five of this
    31  article indicating the issuance of a notice and demand  issued  pursuant
    32  to  section  five  hundred  five  of  this  article shall be prima facie
    33  evidence of any matter stated therein and the courts shall take judicial
    34  notice thereof as if same were certified as  true  under  the  seal  and
    35  signature of the commissioner of housing and community renewal.
    36    3. A court shall not grant the injunctive relief requested pursuant to
    37  subdivision  one  of this section, unless, at least thirty days prior to
    38  the filing requesting the injunction, the owner of the affected property
    39  has received written notice of the violation of standards  contained  in
    40  section  five  hundred  one  of this article and has failed to bring the
    41  affected property into compliance with the  applicable  standards.  This
    42  notice  to  the  owner of the affected property is satisfied when any of
    43  the following has occurred:
    44    (a) A person or their attorney, has notified the owner of an  affected
    45  property  that  the property fails to meet the requirements of paragraph
    46  (b) of subdivision one of section five hundred one of this article;
    47    (b) The deputy commissioner, the commissioner of housing and community
    48  renewal, or the designee of either of these such officials, a  municipal
    49  or  other  local  authority  with responsibility for enforcing any local
    50  housing code or codes, or a local or municipal department of health  has
    51  notified  the  owner  of  the  affected  property  of  violations of the
    52  provisions of this article occurring within an affected property  or  of
    53  the failure to register and file reports as required by this article; or
    54    (c)  A  criminal  or  civil  action  pursuant to this article has been
    55  brought by either state or local enforcement officials to  enforce  this
    56  article.

        S. 2947                            17

     1    4.  The  notice requirement of subdivision three of this section shall
     2  not apply  with  respect  to  applications  for  preliminary  injunctive
     3  relief.
     4    5.  A tenant or occupant or other interested person who prevails in an
     5  action to enforce the provisions of this article is entitled to an award
     6  of the costs of the litigation and to an award of reasonable  attorneys'
     7  fees in an amount to be fixed by the court.
     8    6.  The  removal of an occupant or tenant from or the surrender by the
     9  occupant or tenant of a dwelling with respect to which an injunction has
    10  been issued pursuant to this  section  shall  not  absolve,  relieve  or
    11  discharge  any  persons  chargeable  therewith  from  the obligation and
    12  responsibility to comply with any orders to comply  with  this  article.
    13  For the purposes of this subdivision, "removal of an occupant or tenant"
    14  shall include vacate or condemnation orders.
    15    7.  Cases brought before the court under this section shall be granted
    16  an accelerated hearing.
    17    8. The legal remedies created under this section shall be in  addition
    18  to  any  other common law or statutory remedies, which may be pursued in
    19  the same or separate action or proceeding.
    20    § 507. Retaliatory evictions prohibited. 1. An owner  of  an  affected
    21  property  may  not evict or take any other retaliatory action against an
    22  occupant or tenant in response to the actions of the occupant, tenant or
    23  other persons in:
    24    (a) providing information to the owner of the affected  property,  the
    25  commissioner  of  housing  and  community  renewal,  the commissioner of
    26  health, or the designee of either of these officials, a local or munici-
    27  pal department of health, or a municipal or other local  authority  with
    28  responsibility  for enforcing any local housing code or codes concerning
    29  lead-based paint hazards within an affected property or  elevated  blood
    30  lead  levels  of  a  person  who resides or has recently resided in that
    31  dwelling; or
    32    (b) enforcing any of his or her rights under this article.
    33    2. An owner of an affected property may not evict or  take  any  other
    34  retaliatory action against an occupant in response to the actions of any
    35  state or local agency to enforce the provisions of this article.
    36    3.  For purposes of this section, a retaliatory action includes any of
    37  the following actions in which the activities protected  under  subdivi-
    38  sion  one  of  this  section  are  a  material factor in motivating said
    39  action:
    40    (a) A refusal to renew a lease;
    41    (b) Termination of a tenancy;
    42    (c) An arbitrary rent increase or decrease in services  to  which  the
    43  occupant is entitled; or
    44    (d) Any form of constructive eviction.
    45    4. An occupant subject to an eviction or retaliatory action under this
    46  section  is  entitled to the relief as may be provided by statute and/or
    47  any further relief deemed just and equitable by the court, and is eligi-
    48  ble for reasonable attorneys' fees and costs.
    49    § 508. Lead poisoning prevention fee. 1. Beginning on  January  first,
    50  two  thousand  twenty-four,  a fee is imposed on manufacturers or whole-
    51  salers of paint sold in the state to support  the  residential  property
    52  lead-based paint hazard abatement revolving loan fund established pursu-
    53  ant to section ninety-nine-qq of the state finance law. The fee shall be
    54  imposed  at the manufacturer or wholesaler level, in the amount of fifty
    55  cents per gallon of paint estimated to have been sold within  the  state
    56  during the prior year, as determined by rule adopted by the division.

        S. 2947                            18

     1    2. The division shall adopt rules to implement this section, including
     2  rules  to  determine which manufacturers or wholesalers of paint sold in
     3  the state are responsible for the fees imposed under subdivision one  of
     4  this  section  and rules establishing the estimated number of gallons of
     5  paint  sold  in  the  state  in the prior year for each manufacturer and
     6  rules determining the manner of payment. The  rules  shall  provide  for
     7  waivers  of  payment  for manufacturers and wholesalers of paint that is
     8  sold in low quantities in the state. The costs for administration of the
     9  residential property lead-based paint hazard  abatement  revolving  loan
    10  fund may be reimbursed from the fees collected.
    11    3.  The  attorney  general  shall  enforce  payment of fees under this
    12  section through an action in the supreme court in Albany county and  may
    13  collect costs and attorneys' fees.
    14    §  509.  Designation  of  exempt municipalities; minimum standards for
    15  lead-based paint poisoning prevention programs. 1. The  commissioner  of
    16  housing  and  community  renewal  may,  by  regulation,  designate as an
    17  "exempt municipality" such other municipalities that  enact  local  laws
    18  for the prevention of childhood lead poisoning that contain at least all
    19  of the following elements:
    20    (a)  Provide  that  residential property units rented to families with
    21  children under age seven shall:
    22    (i) be maintained free of conditions that would constitute a condition
    23  conducive to lead poisoning; and
    24    (ii) be inspected either by appropriately-trained and accredited local
    25  governmental inspectors no less frequently than every two years,  or  by
    26  property  owners no less frequently than every year, for the presence of
    27  conditions conducive to lead poisoning, and provide that the results  of
    28  such  inspections  shall be provided in writing to the occupants of such
    29  dwellings and maintained for ten years.
    30    (b) Provide for the inspection for, and removal of, conditions  condu-
    31  cive to lead poisoning prior to the renting of residential properties.
    32    (c) Provide that any activities that disturb lead-based paint or paint
    33  of  unknown  lead  content  in dwellings or dwelling units with children
    34  under age seven, and the common areas of such  dwellings,  be  performed
    35  only  by  personnel who have met the requirements established in section
    36  five hundred three of this article.
    37    (d) Provide a private right of action  by  tenants  or  occupants  for
    38  violations of such local law.
    39    2.  Notwithstanding  any  local  law  to  the  contrary, no local lead
    40  poisoning prevention law or program may employ standards for "lead-based
    41  paint," "lead-contaminated dust," and "soil-lead hazard" that  are  less
    42  protective of public health than those set forth in section five hundred
    43  one  of this article or such more stringent levels adopted by regulation
    44  by the division of housing and community renewal.
    45    § 510. Reporting. 1. Within three months after the close of the fiscal
    46  year, the deputy commissioner, in consultation with the commissioner  of
    47  health and commissioner of labor or her or his designee, shall report to
    48  the  advisory  council established in section thirteen hundred seventy-b
    49  of the public health law on the implementation of  this  article  during
    50  the  preceding period. Such report shall be publicly available and shall
    51  include, at a minimum, a detailed statement of revenue and  expenditures
    52  and  statement  of  the  division's  program, supported by a statistical
    53  section with geographic indexing designed to provide a detailed explana-
    54  tion of the division's enforcement, including but  not  limited  to  the
    55  following:

        S. 2947                            19

     1    (a)  the  number  of dwelling units inspected by the division or other
     2  state or local agency pursuant  to  this  article,  and  the  number  of
     3  inspectors assigned to conduct such inspections;
     4    (b)  the  number of dwelling units in which the occupant complained of
     5  violations of this article and the number of dwelling units in which the
     6  existence of such conditions were confirmed by  the  division  or  other
     7  state or local agency;
     8    (c)  a  statistical profile of dwellings in which violations have been
     9  placed pursuant to this title and pursuant to this  article,  indicating
    10  the  ages  of the dwellings and other factors relevant to the prevalence
    11  of lead-based paint hazards, which may include the prior lead poisonings
    12  or reports of persons with elevated blood lead levels in  the  dwelling,
    13  outstanding  violations, emergency repair charges, tax arrears and mort-
    14  gage debt;
    15    (d) an evaluation of the  division's  capability  to  timely  inspect,
    16  serve a notice of violation, and enforce the correction of violations;
    17    (e)  the  enforcement actions brought pursuant to section five hundred
    18  five of this article, the identity of the owners of the affected proper-
    19  ties, the authority bringing the enforcement action, the nature  of  the
    20  action, and describing the criminal penalties and/or civil relief; and
    21    (f)  an  evaluation  of  the division's implementation of a program of
    22  inspection pursuant to section five hundred two of this article.
    23    2. The commissioner of housing and community renewal shall designate a
    24  deputy commissioner responsible for fulfilling the  objectives  of  this
    25  title when such objectives involve the responsibilities of the division.
    26    §  4. The labor law is amended by adding a new article 32-A to read as
    27  follows:
    28                                ARTICLE 32-A
    29            NEW YORK LICENSING OF LEAD INSPECTORS AND CONTRACTORS
    30  Section 949-a. Definitions.
    31          949-b. Accreditation of inspectors  and  contractors  performing
    32                   lead-based paint activities.
    33    § 949-a. Definitions. As used in this article:
    34    1. "Abatement" means any measure or set of measures designed to perma-
    35  nently  eliminate  lead-based  paint  hazards,  as defined by the United
    36  States environmental protection agency pursuant to  40  CFR  745.220  or
    37  successor regulation.
    38    2.  "Deteriorated paint" means any interior or exterior paint or other
    39  coating that is curling, scaling, flaking,  blistering,  peeling,  chip-
    40  ping,  chalking,  cracking, or loose in any manner, such that a space or
    41  pocket of air is behind a portion thereof or such that the paint is  not
    42  completely adhered to the underlying subsurface, or is otherwise damaged
    43  or separated from the substrate.
    44    3. "Deteriorated subsurface" shall mean an unstable or unsound painted
    45  subsurface,  an  indication  of  which  can be observed through a visual
    46  inspection, including, but not limited to, rotted or  decayed  wood,  or
    47  wood or plaster that has been subject to moisture or disturbance.
    48    4.  "Dwelling"  means  a  building  or  structure  or portion thereof,
    49  including the property occupied by and  appurtenant  to  such  dwelling,
    50  which is occupied in whole or in part as the home, residence or sleeping
    51  place  of one or more human beings and shall, without limiting the fore-
    52  going, include child care facilities for children under seven  years  of
    53  age, kindergartens and nursery schools.
    54    5.  "Friction  surface"  means an interior or exterior painted surface
    55  that touches or is in contact with another surface, such  that  the  two
    56  surfaces are capable of relative motion and abrade, scrape, or bind when

        S. 2947                            20

     1  in  relative motion. Friction surfaces shall include, but not be limited
     2  to, window frames and jambs, doors, and hinges.
     3    6. "Impact surface" means an interior or exterior painted surface that
     4  shows  evidence,  such  as  marking,  denting,  or  chipping, that it is
     5  subject to damage by repeated sudden force, such  as  certain  parts  of
     6  door frames, moldings, or baseboards.
     7    7. "Inspection" means a surface-by-surface investigation in a dwelling
     8  to  determine  the  presence  of lead-based paint and the provision of a
     9  report explaining the results of the investigation.
    10    8. "Lead-based paint" means paint or  other  similar  surface  coating
    11  material  containing  0.5  milligrams  of  lead per square centimeter or
    12  greater, as determined by laboratory analysis of paint samples with  all
    13  layers  of  paint  present,  or by an x-ray fluorescence analyzer. If an
    14  x-ray fluorescence analyzer is used, readings  shall  be  corrected  for
    15  substrate bias when necessary as specified by the performance character-
    16  istic  sheets  released  by  the  United States environmental protection
    17  agency (EPA) and the United  States  department  of  housing  and  urban
    18  development  (HUD)  for  the  specific x-ray fluorescence analyzer used.
    19  X-ray fluorescence readings shall be classified as positive, negative or
    20  inconclusive in accordance with the United States department of  housing
    21  and urban development guidelines for the evaluation and control of lead-
    22  based  paint  hazards in housing (July 2012) and the performance charac-
    23  teristic sheets released by the EPA for the specific x-ray  fluorescence
    24  analyzer  used.  X-ray fluorescence readings that fall within the incon-
    25  clusive zone, as determined by the  performance  characteristic  sheets,
    26  shall  be confirmed by laboratory analysis of paint chips, results shall
    27  be reported in milligrams of lead per square centimeter and the  measure
    28  of  such laboratory analysis shall be definitive. If laboratory analysis
    29  is used to determine lead content, results shall be reported  in  milli-
    30  grams  of lead per square centimeter.  Where the surface area of a paint
    31  chip sample cannot be accurately measured or if an  accurately  measured
    32  paint  chip  sample  cannot  be  removed,  a  laboratory analysis may be
    33  reported in percent by weight. In such case, lead-based paint shall mean
    34  any paint or other similar surface-coating material containing more than
    35  0.25% of metallic lead, based on the non-volatile content of  the  paint
    36  or  other similar surface-coating material. In the event that the EPA or
    37  a successor agency, or the HUD or a successor agency, or a department or
    38  agency of the state of New York that has  obtained  applicable  authori-
    39  zation pursuant to 40 C.F.R. part 745 subpart Q or successor regulation,
    40  adopts  more stringent definitions of lead-based paint, such more strin-
    41  gent definitions shall apply for the purposes of this article.
    42    9. "Lead-based  paint  activities"  means,  in  the  case  of  housing
    43  constructed  before  nineteen  seventy-eight, and child-occupied facili-
    44  ties, inspection, risk assessment, and abatement.
    45    10. "Lead-based paint hazard" means any condition in, or proximate to,
    46  a dwelling or dwelling unit that causes exposure to lead from  lead-con-
    47  taminated  dust,  from  lead-based  paint  that is deteriorated, or from
    48  lead-based paint that is  present  on  chewable  surfaces,  deteriorated
    49  subsurfaces,  friction  surfaces,  or  impact surfaces, or in soil, that
    50  would result in adverse human health effects.
    51    11. "Lead-contaminated dust" means surface dust that contains  a  mass
    52  per  area  concentration  of lead equal to or exceeding 5 micrograms per
    53  square foot ("ug/ft2") on floors, or 40 ug/ft2 on  interior  windowsills
    54  based on wipe sample, or 100 ug/ft2 on window wells, or such more strin-
    55  gent  standards  as may be adopted by the commissioner of health, except
    56  that, if the United States environmental protection agency or a  succes-

        S. 2947                            21

     1  sor  agency, or the United States department of housing and urban devel-
     2  opment or a successor agency, adopts more stringent definitions of lead-
     3  contaminated dust, such definitions shall apply for the purposes of this
     4  article.
     5    12.  "Risk assessment" means (a) an on-site investigation to determine
     6  the existence,  nature,  severity,  and  location  of  lead-based  paint
     7  hazards, and (b) the provision of a report by the individual or the firm
     8  conducting  the  risk assessment, explaining the results of the investi-
     9  gation and options for reducing lead-based paint hazards.
    10    § 949-b. Accreditation of inspectors and contractors performing  lead-
    11  based paint activities. The commissioner shall adopt regulations, suffi-
    12  cient  to  satisfy  the  requirements  of 40 C.F.R. 745.325 or successor
    13  regulation, governing (a) procedures and requirements for  the  accredi-
    14  tation  of lead-based paint activities training programs, (b) procedures
    15  and requirements for the certification of individuals engaged  in  lead-
    16  based  paint  activities, (c) work practice standards for the conduct of
    17  lead-based paint activities, (d) requirements that all lead-based  paint
    18  activities  be conducted by appropriately certified contractors, and (e)
    19  development of the appropriate infrastructure or government capacity  to
    20  effectively  carry  out  clear enforcement mechanisms and procedures for
    21  unannounced compliance inspections of properties and for  responding  to
    22  complaints.
    23    §  5.  The tax law is amended by adding a new section 187-r to read as
    24  follows:
    25    § 187-r. Lead hazard reduction tax credit. 1. Tax  credit  for  activ-
    26  ities  resulting in lead-free or lead-contained status. A taxpayer shall
    27  be allowed a credit against taxes imposed by this article for activities
    28  necessary to bring any affected property  into  lead-free  or  lead-con-
    29  tained status within the meaning of section five hundred one of the real
    30  property law, provided that the taxpayer complies with the documentation
    31  requirements of subdivision four of this section.
    32    2.  Tax credit for multiple dwelling units located within exempt muni-
    33  cipalities. A taxpayer also shall be eligible for the tax  credit  under
    34  subdivision  one  of  this section if a dwelling unit that satisfies all
    35  the requirements for an affected property contained in  subdivision  two
    36  of  section five hundred of the real property law but such dwelling unit
    37  is located in an exempt municipality within the meaning of section  five
    38  hundred  of  the  real  property  law.  In such case, the taxpayer shall
    39  comply with equivalent standards in local laws concerning  lead  hazards
    40  that apply to multiple dwellings.
    41    3.  Tax credits for certain renovations as part of achieving lead-sta-
    42  bilized status. A taxpayer shall  be  allowed  a  credit  against  taxes
    43  imposed by this article for the costs of certain activities necessary to
    44  bring any affected property into lead-stabilized status within the mean-
    45  ing  of section five hundred one of the real property law, provided that
    46  the expected useful life of such renovations is ten years  or  more  and
    47  the taxpayer complies with the documentation requirements of subdivision
    48  four  of this section. The commissioner of housing and community renewal
    49  shall promulgate regulations  defining  those  activities  necessary  to
    50  achieve lead-stabilized status with an expected useful life of more than
    51  ten  years. Taxpayers who have completed renovations of habitable dwell-
    52  ing units contained in multiple dwellings, as defined in section four of
    53  the multiple dwelling law, in an exempt municipality within the  meaning
    54  of  section  five  hundred  of the real property law, shall be allowed a
    55  credit under this subdivision provided that the taxpayer  complies  with

        S. 2947                            22

     1  similar  standards  in  local laws concerning lead hazards that apply to
     2  multiple dwellings.
     3    4.  Documentation  required  for  credit allowance. No credit shall be
     4  allowed under subdivisions one, two or three of this section unless  the
     5  taxpayer provides documentation to the division of housing and community
     6  renewal that:
     7    (a) the activities described above have been performed by a contractor
     8  accredited  pursuant  to  section five hundred four of the real property
     9  law;
    10    (b) the affected property was constructed prior  to  nineteen  hundred
    11  seventy;
    12    (c) the taxpayer has paid for the activities described above; and
    13    (d)  includes a written certification obtained by the taxpayer from an
    14  inspector, accredited pursuant to section five hundred four of the  real
    15  property law, that the activities described above have been completed in
    16  accordance with all applicable requirements and that either:
    17    (i)  Where  applicable, the affected property or property unit can now
    18  be certified as either lead-free or lead-contained  under  section  five
    19  hundred one of the real property law; or
    20    (ii) Where applicable, the affected property has undergone renovations
    21  that  satisfy the requirements established by regulation by the division
    22  of housing and community renewal  as  activities  necessary  to  achieve
    23  lead-stabilized  status  with  an  expected useful life of more than ten
    24  years.
    25    5. Amount of credit. The tax credit shall be equal to the amount actu-
    26  ally paid for the activities described in this subdivision up to a maxi-
    27  mum of three thousand dollars per affected property for a credit allowed
    28  under either subdivision one or two of this section or a maximum of  one
    29  thousand  five  hundred  dollars  for a credit allowed under subdivision
    30  three of this section.
    31    6. Carry-over of credit. Any amount of tax  credit  not  used  in  the
    32  taxable  year of certification may be carried forward and applied to the
    33  corporation's tax liability for any one or more of the  succeeding  five
    34  taxable  years.  The  credit  may not be applied until all other credits
    35  available to the taxpayer for that taxable year have been applied.
    36    § 6. Section 606 of the tax law is amended by adding a new  subsection
    37  (ooo) to read as follows:
    38    (ooo)  Lead-hazard  reduction  in housing tax credit. (1) Allowance of
    39  credit for activities resulting in lead-free or  lead-contained  status.
    40  A  taxpayer shall be allowed a credit as provided in this subsection for
    41  activities necessary to bring any affected property  into  lead-free  or
    42  lead-contained  status within the meaning of section five hundred one of
    43  the real property law, provided that  the  taxpayer  complies  with  the
    44  documentation requirements of paragraph four of this subsection.
    45    (2)  Tax credit for similar dwelling units located within exempt muni-
    46  cipalities within the meaning of section five hundred of the real  prop-
    47  erty  law.  A  taxpayer  also shall be eligible for the tax credit under
    48  paragraph one of this subsection if a dwelling unit that  satisfies  all
    49  the  requirements  for an affected property contained in subdivision two
    50  of section five hundred of the real property law but such dwelling  unit
    51  is  located in an exempt municipality within the meaning of section five
    52  hundred of the real property law.  In  such  case,  the  taxpayer  shall
    53  comply  with  equivalent standards in local laws concerning lead hazards
    54  that apply to multiple dwellings.
    55    (3) Tax credits for certain renovations as part of achieving lead-sta-
    56  bilized status. A taxpayer shall  be  allowed  a  credit  against  taxes

        S. 2947                            23

     1  imposed by this article for the costs of certain activities necessary to
     2  bring any affected property into lead-stabilized status within the mean-
     3  ing  of section five hundred one of the real property law, provided that
     4  the  expected  useful  life of such renovations is ten years or more and
     5  the taxpayer complies with the documentation requirements  of  paragraph
     6  four  of  this  subsection.  The  commissioner  of housing and community
     7  renewal shall promulgate regulations defining those activities necessary
     8  to achieve lead-stabilized status with an expected useful life  of  more
     9  than  ten  years.  Taxpayers who have completed renovations of habitable
    10  dwelling units contained in multiple dwellings, as  defined  in  section
    11  four  of  the multiple dwelling law in an exempt municipality within the
    12  meaning of section five hundred of the real property law also  shall  be
    13  allowed  a  credit  under  this  paragraph  provided  that  the taxpayer
    14  complies with similar standards in local laws  concerning  lead  hazards
    15  that apply to multiple dwellings.
    16    (4)  Documentation  required  for credit allowance. No credit shall be
    17  allowed under paragraph one, two or three of this subsection unless  the
    18  taxpayer provides documentation to the division of housing and community
    19  renewal that:
    20    (A) the activities described above have been performed by a contractor
    21  accredited  pursuant  to  section five hundred four of the real property
    22  law;
    23    (B) the affected property was constructed prior  to  nineteen  hundred
    24  seventy;
    25    (C) the taxpayer has paid for the activities described above; and
    26    (D)  includes a written certification obtained by the taxpayer from an
    27  inspector, accredited pursuant to section five hundred four of the  real
    28  property law, that the activities described above have been completed in
    29  accordance with all applicable requirements and that either:
    30    (i)  where  applicable,  the affected property can now be certified as
    31  either lead-free or lead-contained under section five hundred one of the
    32  real property law; or
    33    (ii) where applicable, the affected property has undergone renovations
    34  that satisfy the requirements established by regulation by the  division
    35  of  housing  and  community  renewal  as activities necessary to achieve
    36  lead-stabilized status with an expected useful life  of  more  than  ten
    37  years.
    38    (5)  The  tax credit pursuant to this subsection shall be available to
    39  someone who owns and occupies his or her own dwelling unit in  the  same
    40  manner  and  to  the  same  extent as it is available to the owner of an
    41  affected property who leases the premises.
    42    (6) Amount of credit. The tax credit shall  be  equal  to  the  amount
    43  actually  paid  for  the activities described in this subsection up to a
    44  maximum of three thousand dollars per affected  property  for  a  credit
    45  allowed  under either paragraph one or two of this subsection or a maxi-
    46  mum of one thousand five hundred dollars  for  a  credit  allowed  under
    47  paragraph three of this subsection.
    48    (7)  Application  of  credit. Any amount of tax credit not used in the
    49  taxable year of certification may be carried forward and applied to  the
    50  individual's  tax  liability  for any one or more of the succeeding five
    51  taxable years. The credit may not be applied  until  all  other  credits
    52  available to the taxpayer for that taxable year have been applied.
    53    § 7. The state finance law is amended by adding a new section 99-qq to
    54  read as follows:
    55    §  99-qq.  Residential  property  lead-based  paint  hazard  abatement
    56  revolving loan fund. 1. There is created, as a separate fund within  the

        S. 2947                            24

     1  general  fund,  in  the custody of the comptroller a fund to be known as
     2  the residential property lead-based  paint  hazard  abatement  revolving
     3  loan fund. Such fund shall consist of proceeds received from the sale of
     4  bonds pursuant to subdivision two of this section, fees collected pursu-
     5  ant to section five hundred eight of the real property law, and any sums
     6  that  the  state  may  from  time  to  time deem appropriate, as well as
     7  donations, gifts, bequests, or otherwise  from  any  public  or  private
     8  source,  which money is intended to assist owners of residential proper-
     9  ties in meeting the standards for  either  lead-free  or  lead-contained
    10  certification  pursuant to section five hundred one of the real property
    11  law, or, for multiple dwellings in an  exempt  municipality  within  the
    12  meaning  of  section  five  hundred of the real property law, compliance
    13  with local laws concerning the control of lead-based  paint  hazards  in
    14  such multiple dwellings.
    15    2.  The state shall issue bonds in an amount specified for the purpose
    16  of funding the residential property lead abatement revolving loan fund.
    17    (a) Any bonds issued or to be  issued  pursuant  to  this  subdivision
    18  shall  be  subject to all the requirements and conditions established by
    19  the state for the sale of bonds.
    20    (b) The interest rate and other terms  upon  which  bonds  are  issued
    21  pursuant  to  this subdivision shall not create a prospective obligation
    22  of the state of New York in excess of the amount of  revenues  that  can
    23  reasonably  be  expected  from  the  loan  repayments, interests on such
    24  loans, and fees that the state of New  York  can  reasonably  expect  to
    25  charge  under  the  provisions  of article nineteen of the real property
    26  law.
    27    (c) All money received from the sale of bonds shall be deposited  into
    28  the residential property lead abatement revolving loan fund.
    29    3. The comptroller shall contract for the administration and disburse-
    30  ment of funding. The deputy commissioner of health shall adopt rules and
    31  regulations which provide for the orderly and equitable disbursement and
    32  repayment of funds.
    33    4.  Funds  placed  in the residential property lead-based paint hazard
    34  abatement revolving loan fund shall be made available, at the discretion
    35  of the commissioner of the division of housing and community renewal, to
    36  the owners of affected properties including those located within  exempt
    37  municipalities  within  the  meaning of section five hundred of the real
    38  property law, and to non-profit organizations for the purpose of  bring-
    39  ing  affected  properties  into  compliance with the standards for lead-
    40  free, lead-contained, or lead-stabilized property status as specified by
    41  section five hundred one of the real  property  law,  or,  for  multiple
    42  dwellings  in  an exempt municipality within the meaning of section five
    43  hundred of the real property law, compliance with local laws  concerning
    44  the  control  of lead-based paint hazards in such multiple dwellings. An
    45  owner of a pre-nineteen hundred seventy property who owns  and  occupies
    46  the  dwelling unit shall be eligible for loans under this section in the
    47  same manner, and to the same extent, as an owner of an affected  proper-
    48  ty.
    49    5.  Loans  made  available under the provisions of this section may be
    50  made directly, or in cooperation with other public and private  lenders,
    51  or  any  agency,  department, or bureau of the federal government or the
    52  state.
    53    6. The proceeds from the repayment of any loans made for that  purpose
    54  shall  be  deposited  in  and  returned to the residential property lead
    55  abatement revolving loan fund to constitute a continuing revolving  fund
    56  for the purposes provided in this section.

        S. 2947                            25

     1    7. The deputy commissioner of housing and community renewal shall take
     2  any  action  necessary  to  obtain  federal  assistance  for lead hazard
     3  reduction to be used in conjunction with the residential  property  lead
     4  abatement revolving loan fund.
     5    §  8.    Paragraph a of subdivision 2 of section 302-a of the multiple
     6  dwelling law, as added by chapter 911 of the laws of 1965, is amended to
     7  read as follows:
     8    a. A "rent impairing" violation within the  meaning  of  this  section
     9  shall designate a condition in a multiple dwelling which, in the opinion
    10  of  the  department,  constitutes,  or  if  not promptly corrected, will
    11  constitute, a fire hazard, a lead-based paint hazard within the  meaning
    12  of  subdivision  twenty-six of section five hundred of the real property
    13  law, or a serious threat to the life,  health  or  safety  of  occupants
    14  thereof.
    15    §  9.  Paragraph  a  of subdivision 2 of section 305-a of the multiple
    16  residence law, as added by chapter 291 of the laws of 1966,  is  amended
    17  to read as follows:
    18    a.  A  "rent  impairing"  violation within the meaning of this section
    19  shall designate a condition in a multiple dwelling which, in the opinion
    20  of the state building code council,  constitutes,  or  if  not  promptly
    21  corrected,  will  constitute,  a  fire hazard, a lead-based paint hazard
    22  within the meaning of subdivision twenty-six of section five hundred  of
    23  the real property law, or a serious threat to the life, health or safety
    24  of occupants thereof.
    25    § 10. The social services law is amended by adding a new section 131-y
    26  to read as follows:
    27    § 131-y. Supplemental shelter allowance. Every public welfare official
    28  shall  pay,  in addition to the shelter allowance components established
    29  by the department pursuant to section one hundred thirty-one-a  of  this
    30  title,  a  supplemental  shelter allowance for units for which the owner
    31  has submitted documentation certifying that  the  dwelling  unit  is  in
    32  compliance  with  subdivision seven of section one hundred forty-three-b
    33  of this title. This monthly lead-safe housing supplement shall be in the
    34  amount of one hundred dollars for efficiency or one-bedroom  units;  one
    35  hundred  fifty  dollars  for  two-bedroom units; two hundred dollars for
    36  three-bedroom units; and two hundred fifty dollars for units  with  four
    37  or more bedrooms; or such higher amounts as the department may establish
    38  by regulation as appropriate to induce landlords in high risk lead-paint
    39  poisoning  areas  to  voluntarily  remove  lead-paint hazards from their
    40  units using lead safe work practices. This supplemental  shelter  allow-
    41  ance  for  lead-safe housing shall be paid for a period of twelve months
    42  following the submission of the most recent certification of  compliance
    43  and  shall  be  renewed  for  subsequent  twelve-month  periods upon the
    44  submission of further  certifications  of  compliance  based  upon  more
    45  recent inspections.
    46    §  11.  Subdivision  2 of section 143-b of the social services law, as
    47  added by chapter 997 of the laws of 1962, is amended and a new  subdivi-
    48  sion 7 is added to read as follows:
    49    2.  Every  public welfare official shall have power to and [may] shall
    50  withhold the payment of any such rent in any case where he  or  she  has
    51  knowledge that there exists or there is outstanding any violation of law
    52  in  respect  to the building containing the housing accommodations occu-
    53  pied by the person entitled  to  such  assistance  which  is  dangerous,
    54  hazardous  or  detrimental  to  life  or  health.  A report of each such
    55  violation shall be made to the appropriate public welfare department  by

        S. 2947                            26

     1  the   appropriate   department   or   agency  having  jurisdiction  over
     2  violations.
     3    7. No state or local agency shall arrange to place a family consisting
     4  of  a  person  or  persons  under seven years of age or a known pregnant
     5  woman in any dwelling unit constructed prior to nineteen hundred  seven-
     6  ty, or, in cities with a population of one million or more, any dwelling
     7  unit constructed prior to nineteen hundred sixty, for which rent is paid
     8  in  any  part  with state funds unless such dwelling unit has been first
     9  inspected by a person accredited pursuant to section five  hundred  four
    10  of  the real property law, and determined to be free of lead-based paint
    11  hazards, as defined by subdivision twenty-six of section five hundred of
    12  the real property law, and unless such agency has first obtained  appro-
    13  priate  documentation  acceptable to the commissioner that such dwelling
    14  unit is in compliance with the requirements of section five hundred  one
    15  of  the real property law, or, for multiple dwellings in an exempt muni-
    16  cipality within the meaning of section five hundred of the real property
    17  law, in compliance with local laws concerning the control of  lead-based
    18  paint  hazards  in  such  multiple  dwellings. A written report shall be
    19  prepared of any inspection performed pursuant to  this  subdivision  and
    20  shall be provided to the family.
    21    §  12. Section 390-a of the social services law is amended by adding a
    22  new subdivision 2-a to read as follows:
    23    2-a. No license or registration shall be issued to a  child  day  care
    24  center,  a  family day care home, or a group family day care home and no
    25  such registration shall be renewed until it  can  be  demonstrated  that
    26  those  portions  of  the  facility  in which such child day care center,
    27  family day care home, or group family day care home is located and those
    28  portions of such facility that are readily  accessible  to  children  in
    29  such  child  day  care center, family day care home, or group family day
    30  care home, meet the standards for lead-free property  status,  lead-con-
    31  tained  property status, or lead-stabilized property status set forth in
    32  section five hundred one of the real  property  law,  or,  for  multiple
    33  dwellings  in an exempt municipality within the meaning of section five-
    34  hundred of the real property law, with all  local  laws  concerning  the
    35  control  of  lead-based  paint  hazards  that apply to multiple dwelling
    36  units where children reside.
    37    § 13. Subdivision 2 of section 1370  of  the  public  health  law,  as
    38  amended  by  chapter  485  of  the  laws  of 1992, is amended to read as
    39  follows:
    40    2. "Area of high risk" means an area designated as such by the commis-
    41  sioner or his or her representative, in conjunction with the commission-
    42  er of housing and community renewal,  and  consisting  of  one  or  more
    43  dwellings  in  which a condition conducive to lead poisoning of children
    44  is present or, additionally, any census tract or block group within  the
    45  state where, during any single year, more than twenty-five children have
    46  been identified with elevated blood lead levels.
    47    § 14. Section 1370-a of the public health law is amended by adding two
    48  new subdivisions 4 and 5 to read as follows:
    49    4.  The  department shall, in conjunction with the division of housing
    50  and community renewal pursuant to section five hundred two of  the  real
    51  property  law,  identify  and designate as areas of high risk any census
    52  tract or block group in the state in which during any single year,  more
    53  than  twenty-five children have been identified with elevated blood lead
    54  levels.
    55    5. Within three months after the close of the fiscal year, the commis-
    56  sioner, in collaboration with the deputy commissioner of the division of

        S. 2947                            27

     1  housing and community renewal, shall  report  to  the  advisory  council
     2  established  in  section thirteen hundred seventy-b of this title on the
     3  department's implementation of this section during the preceding period.
     4  Such report shall be publicly available and shall include, at a minimum,
     5  a  detailed  statement  of revenue and expenditures and statement of the
     6  department's program, supported by a statistical section with geographic
     7  indexing designed to provide a detailed explanation of the  department's
     8  enforcement, including but not limited to the following:
     9    (a)  a  statistical profile of dwellings in which violations have been
    10  placed pursuant to this title and pursuant to article  nineteen  of  the
    11  real  property  law,  indicating  the  ages  of  the dwellings and other
    12  factors relevant to the prevalence of lead-based  paint  hazards,  which
    13  may  include the prior lead poisonings or reports of elevated blood lead
    14  levels of occupants in the dwelling, outstanding  violations,  emergency
    15  repair charges, tax arrears and mortgage debt;
    16    (b)  the number of dwelling units inspected by the department or other
    17  state or local agency pursuant to this  title  or  pursuant  to  article
    18  nineteen of the real property law, and the number of inspectors assigned
    19  to conduct such inspections;
    20    (c)  the  number of dwelling units in which the occupant complained of
    21  peeling paint or a deteriorated subsurface and the number  of  pre-nine-
    22  teen hundred seventy-eight dwelling units in which the existence of such
    23  conditions  were  confirmed  by  the  department or other state or local
    24  agency;
    25    (d) the number of dwelling units in which the occupant complained of a
    26  violation of article nineteen of the real property law and the number of
    27  pre-nineteen hundred seventy-eight dwelling units in which the existence
    28  of such conditions were confirmed by the division of housing and  commu-
    29  nity renewal or other state or local agency;
    30    (e)  the  number  of  dwelling  units  in which a violation was placed
    31  pursuant to this title, whether the violation was placed in response  to
    32  an occupant's complaint or otherwise;
    33    (f) the number of dwelling units in which a violation of article nine-
    34  teen  of  the  real  property  law was placed, whether the violation was
    35  placed in response to an occupant's complaint or otherwise;
    36    (g) an evaluation of the department's capability  to  timely  inspect,
    37  serve a notice of violation, and enforce the correction of violations;
    38    (h)  an  evaluation of the division of housing and community renewal's
    39  capability to timely inspect, serve a notice of violation,  and  enforce
    40  the correction of violations;
    41    (i)  an  evaluation of the division of housing and community renewal's
    42  implementation of a program  of  inspection  pursuant  to  section  five
    43  hundred two of the real property law; and
    44    (j) a tabulation of all municipalities, census tracts, or census block
    45  groups  which  have  in  any  year  more  than twenty-five children with
    46  elevated blood lead levels, including totals of the number  of  children
    47  with such elevated blood lead levels by five point increments.
    48    §  15.  Subdivision  1  of  section  1371 of the public health law, as
    49  amended by chapter 485 of the laws of 1992 and as designated by  chapter
    50  721 of the laws of 1993, is amended to read as follows:
    51    1. No person shall manufacture, sell or hold for sale a children's toy
    52  or  children's  furniture  having paint or other similar surface-coating
    53  material thereon containing more than [.06] .009 of one per  centum  (90
    54  parts  per  million)  of  metallic lead based on the total weight of the
    55  contained solids or dried paint film.

        S. 2947                            28

     1    § 16. Section 1372 of the public health law, as amended by chapter 485
     2  of the laws of 1992, is amended to read as follows:
     3    §  1372.  Use  of  leaded  paint. No person shall apply paint or other
     4  similar surface-coating material containing more than [.06] .009 of  one
     5  per  centum  (90  parts per million) of metallic lead based on the total
     6  weight of the contained solids or  dried  paint  film  to  any  interior
     7  surface, window sill, window frame or porch of a dwelling.
     8    §  17. This act shall take effect immediately; provided, however, that
     9  section 508 of the real property law, as added by section three of  this
    10  act, shall expire and be deemed repealed when the commissioner of health
    11  certifies  that  a  period of 24 months has elapsed since the department
    12  identified a child with an elevated blood lead level  through  screening
    13  by health care providers under section thirteen hundred seventy-c of the
    14  public health law; provided that the commissioner of health shall notify
    15  the  legislative  bill  drafting  commission  upon the occurrence of the
    16  certification required by this section in order that the commission  may
    17  maintain an accurate and timely effective data base of the official text
    18  of  the laws of the state of New York in furtherance of effectuating the
    19  provisions of section 44 of the legislative law and section 70-b of  the
    20  public officers law.
feedback