Bill Text: NY S03185 | 2023-2024 | General Assembly | Introduced

NOTE: There are more recent revisions of this legislation. Read Latest Draft

---

Bill Title: Prohibits the taking of horseshoe crabs for commercial and biomedical purposes.

Spectrum: Partisan Bill (Democrat 2-0)

Status: (Introduced) 2024-06-07 - SUBSTITUTED BY A10140 [S03185 Detail]

Download: New_York-2023-S03185-Introduced.html

---

                STATE OF NEW YORK
        ________________________________________________________________________

                                          3185

                               2023-2024 Regular Sessions

                    IN SENATE

                                    January 30, 2023
                                       ___________

        Introduced  by Sen. HOYLMAN-SIGAL -- read twice and ordered printed, and
          when printed to be committed to the Committee on Environmental Conser-
          vation

        AN ACT to amend the environmental conservation law, in relation  to  the
          management of horseshoe crabs; and providing for the repeal of certain
          provisions of such law upon expiration thereof

          The  People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assem-
        bly, do enact as follows:

     1    Section 1. Legislative findings.  The legislature hereby finds that:
     2    (a) The horseshoe crab stock assessments issued by the Atlantic States
     3  Marine Fisheries  Commission  (ASMFC)  for  the  New  York  region  have
     4  declined  since 2009, when the population was graded as "good". The 2013
     5  stock assessment graded the population as neutral, and in the 2019 stock
     6  assessment, the Commission downgraded the status of the  horseshoe  crab
     7  population  in  New  York State to "poor". Stock status was based on the
     8  proportion of surveys above or below the 1998  reference  points  estab-
     9  lished when ASMFC management of horseshoe crabs began. In the 2019 stock
    10  assessment, the ASMFC states that, "Continued declines in abundance were
    11  evident  in  the  New  York  and  New England regions. Decreased harvest
    12  quotas in Delaware Bay have potentially  redirected  harvest  to  nearby
    13  regions. Current harvest within the New England and New York regions may
    14  not  be  sustainable.  Continued  precautionary  management is therefore
    15  recommended coast-wide to anticipate effects of redirecting harvest from
    16  Delaware Bay to outlying populations."
    17    (b) The International Union for the Conservation of Nature (IUCN)  has
    18  also  determined that the horseshoe crab meets the Red List criteria and
    19  is  vulnerable  to  local  extinction.  The  IUCN  stated,   "Population
    20  reductions  in  Limulus  have  occurred  over  much of its range, but in
    21  particular within the Mid-Atlantic region. The cause is understood to be
    22  over-harvest, which has been corrected through active management  inter-
    23  vention  over much of the range. An assessment of population trend indi-

         EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
                              [ ] is old law to be omitted.
                                                                   LBD07610-01-3
        S. 3185                             2

     1  cates population stability in the Delaware Bay area of the  Mid-Atlantic
     2  region  and  population  growth  in  the  Southeast region.   Continuing
     3  decreases were found in the Great Bay estuary of New  Hampshire  in  the
     4  Gulf  of  Maine  region,  the  New England and New York areas within the
     5  Mid-Atlantic region and in the Northeast Gulf of Mexico."
     6    (c) Each spring, shorebirds stop at Long Island beaches and feed  upon
     7  horseshoe  crab  eggs.  These include the red knot, dunlin, semipalmated
     8  sandpiper, sanderling, ruddy  turnstone,  greater  yellowlegs,  American
     9  golden-plover,  black-bellied  plover,  buff-breasted  sandpiper, short-
    10  billed dowitcher, purple sandpiper, marbled  godwit,  Hudsonian  godwit,
    11  and whimbrel.
    12    (d)  The red knot was once considered one of the state's most abundant
    13  shorebirds. Horseshoe crab eggs are a critical source of  food  for  red
    14  knots  which  they  consume during their stopover in New York. Such food
    15  source is necessary for the red  knots  to  gain  sufficient  weight  to
    16  continue  their  migration  north  to  breeding  grounds in the Canadian
    17  Arctic. Surveys have shown that red knots have declined  by  75  percent
    18  since the 1980s. Thus, both state and international biologists fear that
    19  the  red knot will become extinct if horseshoe crab populations continue
    20  to decline.
    21    (e) Horseshoe crabs are keystone species, providing an essential  food
    22  source not only for red knots, but also for many other types of bird and
    23  fish species important to New York's commercial and recreational fisher-
    24  ies, as well as birding and fishing tourism. Eels, whelk, catfish, juve-
    25  nile  striped  bass,  white perch, killifish, weakfish, Atlantic silver-
    26  sides, bluefish, sand shrimp, blue crabs, spider crabs, and hermit crabs
    27  all eat horseshoe crab eggs and larvae as part of their diets.
    28    (f) The legislature therefore declares  that  stricter  management  of
    29  horseshoe  crabs  is  necessary  to ensure that more horseshoe crab eggs
    30  will be available as a food source, thus helping to ensure the  survival
    31  of these shorebirds.
    32    §  2.  Subdivision 1 of section 13-0331 of the environmental conserva-
    33  tion law, as amended by chapter 447 of the laws of 2017, is amended  and
    34  two new subdivisions 9 and 10 are added to read as follows:
    35    1.  a.  No person shall take crabs, including horseshoe crabs (Limulus
    36  sp.)  for commercial purposes, or sell or possess with  intent  to  sell
    37  horseshoe  crabs  for  commercial  purposes,  without  first obtaining a
    38  permit from  the  department.  [For  purposes  of  this  subdivision,  a
    39  presumption  of "commercial purposes" shall be made wherein one takes or
    40  lands more than fifty crabs in any one day or sells or barters or offers
    41  for sale or barter any crabs he or she  has  taken.]  Permits  shall  be
    42  issued  to  individuals only but may be endorsed for use on a vessel, in
    43  which case it shall cover all persons on board such vessel.
    44    b. For purposes of this subdivision:
    45    (i) a presumption of "commercial purposes" shall be made  wherein  one
    46  takes  or  lands more than fifty crabs or more than five horseshoe crabs
    47  in any one day or sells or barters or offers  for  sale  or  barter  any
    48  crabs, including horseshoe crabs, he or she has taken; and
    49    (ii)  a  presumption  of  possession with intent to sell shall be made
    50  wherein any horseshoe crabs are possessed  without  a  permit  from  the
    51  department.
    52    9.  a.  Notwithstanding any provision of this section to the contrary,
    53  until December thirty-first, two thousand twenty-eight, no person  shall
    54  take,  sell,  or possess with intent to sell any horseshoe crab (Limulus
    55  sp.) or the eggs of any horseshoe crab, except pursuant to  a  horseshoe
    56  crab bio-medical harvester permit.
        S. 3185                             3

     1    b.  Any person may apply for a horseshoe crab bio-medical harvester or
     2  user permit and the department may issue such  permit  upon  a  determi-
     3  nation  that the permit is for a valid and necessary bio-medical purpose
     4  and that the taking of horseshoe crabs for such purposes  will  have  no
     5  more  than  nominal  impact  to  the  red knot, other shorebirds, or the
     6  horseshoe crab population.
     7    c. When taking horseshoe crabs, a holder of a horseshoe crab bio-medi-
     8  cal harvester permit shall use a manner of catch and release that  mini-
     9  mizes  injury  to  crabs,  and shall release any taken crabs to the same
    10  waters from which they were taken.
    11    d. The taking of horseshoe crabs  incidentally  during  legal  fishing
    12  operations  does  not  violate this section if such crabs are handled in
    13  such a manner to  minimize  harm  to  such  crabs  and  are  immediately
    14  returned to the same waters from which they were taken.
    15    10.  a.  The department shall conduct a study to examine and determine
    16  whether:
    17    (i) the population of red knots has reached recovery targets as deter-
    18  mined by the department; and
    19    (ii) the population of other shorebirds that  rely  on  the  horseshoe
    20  crab  (Limulus  sp.)  or  the  eggs  of the horseshoe crab have remained
    21  stable or increased, including, but not limited to the dunlin,  semipal-
    22  mated sandpiper, sanderling, ruddy turnstone, greater yellowlegs, Ameri-
    23  can golden-plover, black-bellied plover, buff-breasted sandpiper, short-
    24  billed  dowitcher,  purple  sandpiper, marbled godwit, Hudsonian godwit,
    25  and whimbrel; and
    26    (iii) a fisheries management plan demonstrates that an adequate supply
    27  of horseshoe crab eggs exists to ensure population  viability  for  both
    28  shorebirds  and  horseshoe  crabs,  as  well as a sustainable commercial
    29  fishery, pursuant to subdivision one of this section. Evidence that such
    30  a supply of eggs exists may include two  consecutive  stock  assessments
    31  from  the Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission that grade the New
    32  York state horseshoe crabs (Limulus sp.) population as "good."
    33    b. To satisfy the requirements of paragraph a of this subdivision, the
    34  department may rely on reports and population studies  compiled  by  any
    35  state or federal unit of government responsible for wildlife management,
    36  a  land-grant  university,  or nonprofit organizations with expertise in
    37  ornithology.
    38    c. On or before June thirtieth, two thousand twenty-eight, the depart-
    39  ment shall submit a report of its findings, conclusions and  recommenda-
    40  tions  to  the  governor and to the legislature with regard to the study
    41  conducted pursuant to paragraph a of this subdivision.
    42    § 3. This act shall take effect on the thirtieth day  after  it  shall
    43  have  become  a  law;  provided, however, that subdivision 10 of section
    44  13-0331 of the environmental conservation law, as added by  section  two
    45  of this act, shall expire and be deemed repealed on January 1, 2029.