Bill Text: IA SF149 | 2017-2018 | 87th General Assembly | Introduced
Bill Title: A bill for an act relating to the review of administrative rules and the rulemaking process.
Spectrum: Partisan Bill (Republican 1-0)
Status: (Introduced - Dead) 2017-01-31 - Subcommittee: Zaun, Dawson, and Horn. S.J. 187. [SF149 Detail]
Download: Iowa-2017-SF149-Introduced.html
Senate File 149 - Introduced SENATE FILE BY ZAUN A BILL FOR 1 An Act relating to the review of administrative rules and the 2 rulemaking process. 3 BE IT ENACTED BY THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF THE STATE OF IOWA: TLSB 1579XS (4) 87 je/rj PAG LIN 1 1 Section 1. Section 7.17, Code 2017, is amended to read as 1 2 follows: 1 3 7.17 Office of administrative rules coordinator. 1 4 1. The governor shall establish the office of the 1 5 administrative rules coordinator, and appoint its staff, which 1 6 shall be a part of the governor's office. 1 7 2. The administrative rules coordinator shall receive all 1 8 notices and rules adopted pursuant to chapter 17A and provide 1 9 the governor with an opportunity to review and object to any 1 10 rule as provided in chapter 17A. 1 11 3. a. The administrative rules coordinator shall create a 1 12 citizens' committee, consisting of regulators, stakeholders, 1 13 members of the public, and members of the general assembly, 1 14 to advise the administrative rules coordinator on rulemaking 1 15 issues. 1 16 b. The members of the committee shall not be paid a per diem 1 17 but shall be reimbursed for travel expenses. 1 18 Sec. 2. Section 17A.4, subsection 1, paragraph b, Code 2017, 1 19 is amended to read as follows: 1 20 b. (1) Afford all interested persons not less than twenty 1 21 days to submit data, views, or arguments in writing, including 1 22 in an electronic format. If timely requested in writing by 1 23 twenty=five interested persons, by a governmental subdivision, 1 24 by the administrative rules review committee, by an agency, or 1 25 by an association having not less than twenty=five members, the 1 26 agency must give interested persons an opportunity to make oral 1 27 presentation. 1 28 (2) To the extent practicable, the agency shall provide an 1 29 opportunity to make these oral presentations using the Iowa 1 30 communications network or other electronic means and provide 1 31 public access at multiple sites throughout the state. If 1 32 a request is received from twenty=five interested persons 1 33 residing in the same city or county, the agency shall provide 1 34 an opportunity for oral presentation in that city or county. 1 35 (3) The opportunity for oral presentation must be held 2 1 at least twenty days after publication of the notice of its 2 2 time and place in the Iowa administrative bulletin. The 2 3 agency shall consider fully all written and oral submissions 2 4 respecting the proposed rule. Within one hundred eighty 2 5 days following either the notice published according to the 2 6 provisions of paragraph "a" or within one hundred eighty 2 7 days after the last date of the oral presentations on the 2 8 proposed rule, whichever is later, the agency shall adopt a 2 9 rule pursuant to the rulemaking proceeding or shall terminate 2 10 the proceeding by publishing notice of termination in the Iowa 2 11 administrative bulletin. 2 12 Sec. 3. Section 17A.4, subsection 2, Code 2017, is amended 2 13 to read as follows: 2 14 2. An agency shall include in a preamble to each rule 2 15 it adoptsa brief explanation of the principal reasons for 2 16 its actionpursuant to section 17A.5 a concise statement 2 17 of the principal reasons for and against the rule adopted, 2 18 incorporating in the statement the reasons for overruling 2 19 considerations urged against the rule and, if applicable, a 2 20 brief explanation of the principal reasons for its failure 2 21 to provide inthatthe rule for the waiver of the rule in 2 22 specified situations if no such waiver provision is included 2 23 in the rule.This explanatory requirement does not apply when 2 24 the agency adopts a rule that only defines the meaning of a 2 25 provision of law if the agency does not possess delegated 2 26 authority to bind the courts to any extent with its definition. 2 27 In addition, if requested to do so by an interested person, 2 28 either prior to adoption or within thirty days thereafter, the 2 29 agency shall issue a concise statement of the principal reasons 2 30 for and against the rule adopted, incorporating therein the 2 31 reasons for overruling considerations urged against the rule. 2 32 This concise statement shall be issued either at the time of 2 33 the adoption of the rule or within thirty=five days after the 2 34 agency receives the request.2 35 Sec. 4. NEW SECTION. 17A.4B Job impact statement. 3 1 1. a. "Benefit" means the reasonably identifiable and 3 2 quantifiable positive effect or outcome that is expected to 3 3 result from implementation of a rule. 3 4 b. "Cost" means reasonably identifiable, significant, direct 3 5 or indirect, economic impact that is expected to result from 3 6 implementation of and compliance with a rule. 3 7 c. "Cost=benefit analysis" means regulatory analysis 3 8 to provide the public with transparency regarding the 3 9 cost=effectiveness of a rule, including the economic costs 3 10 and benefits and the effectiveness weighed by the agency 3 11 in adopting the rule. "Cost=benefit analysis" includes a 3 12 comparison of the probable costs and benefits of a rule to the 3 13 probable costs and benefits of less intrusive or less expensive 3 14 methods that exist for achieving the purpose of the rule. 3 15 d. "Jobs" means private sector employment including 3 16 self=employment and areas for potential for employment growth. 3 17 e. "Jobs impact statement" means a statement that does all 3 18 of the following: 3 19 (1) Identifies the purpose of a rule and the applicable 3 20 section of the statute that provides specific legal authority 3 21 for the agency to adopt the rule. 3 22 (2) Identifies and describes the cost that the agency 3 23 anticipates state agencies, local governments, the public, and 3 24 the regulated entities, including regulated businesses and 3 25 self=employed individuals, will incur due to implementing and 3 26 complying with a rule. 3 27 (3) Determines whether a rule would have a positive 3 28 or negative impact on private sector jobs and employment 3 29 opportunities in Iowa. 3 30 (4) Describes and quantifies the nature of the impact a rule 3 31 will have on private sector jobs and employment opportunities 3 32 including the categories of jobs and employment opportunities 3 33 that are affected by the rule, and the number of jobs or 3 34 potential job opportunities and the regions of the state 3 35 affected by the rule. 4 1 (5) Identifies, where possible, the additional costs to 4 2 employers per employee due to implementing and complying with 4 3 a rule. 4 4 (6) Includes other relevant analysis requested by the 4 5 administrative rules coordinator. 4 6 2. Prior to implementation of a rule, an agency shall 4 7 take steps to minimize the adverse impact on jobs and 4 8 the development of new employment opportunities due to 4 9 implementation of the rule. 4 10 3. An agency shall provide a jobs impact statement to the 4 11 administrative rules coordinator prior to publication of a 4 12 notice of intended action or the publication of a rule filed 4 13 without notice pursuant to section 17A.4, subsection 3. 4 14 4. The jobs impact statement shall be published as part 4 15 of the preamble to the notice of rulemaking in the Iowa 4 16 administrative bulletin, unless the administrative rules 4 17 coordinator determines that publication of the entire jobs 4 18 impact statement would be unnecessary or impractical. 4 19 5. An agency shall accept comments and information 4 20 from stakeholders prior to final preparation of the jobs 4 21 impact statement. Any concerned private sector employer or 4 22 self=employed individual, potential employer, potential small 4 23 business, or member of the public may submit information 4 24 relating to a jobs impact statement prior to publication of 4 25 a notice of intended action or publication of a rule filed 4 26 without notice pursuant to section 17A.4, subsection 3. An 4 27 agency may request that such information be submitted to the 4 28 agency. 4 29 6. If a jobs impact statement is revised after a notice 4 30 of intended action or a rule filed without notice pursuant to 4 31 section 17A.4, subsection 3, is published, the revised jobs 4 32 impact statement shall be published as part of the preamble 4 33 to the adopted version of the rule, unless the administrative 4 34 rules coordinator determines that publication of the entire 4 35 jobs impact statement would be unnecessary or impractical. 5 1 7. The analysis in the jobs impact statement shall give 5 2 particular weight to jobs in production sectors of the economy 5 3 which includes the manufacturing and agricultural sectors of 5 4 the economy and shall include analysis, where applicable, of 5 5 the impact of the rule on expansion of existing businesses or 5 6 facilities. 5 7 8. The administrative rules coordinator may waive the jobs 5 8 impact statement requirement for rules proposed under section 5 9 17A.4, subsection 3, or section 17A.5, subsection 2, paragraph 5 10 "b", or if unnecessary or impractical. 5 11 9. By July 1, 2018, and every five years thereafter, an 5 12 agency shall prepare a comprehensive jobs impact statement 5 13 for all of the agency's rules. An agency shall transmit 5 14 each five=year comprehensive jobs impact statement to the 5 15 administrative rules coordinator and the administrative rules 5 16 review committee. An agency shall publish the statement, or a 5 17 summary, on the internet site established pursuant to section 5 18 17A.6A. 5 19 Sec. 5. NEW SECTION. 17A.4C Negotiated rulemaking. 5 20 1. An agency shall create a negotiated rulemaking group if 5 21 required by statute. An agency may, on its own motion or upon 5 22 request, create a negotiated rulemaking group if the agency 5 23 determines that a negotiated rulemaking group can adequately 5 24 represent the interests that will be significantly affected by 5 25 a draft rule proposal and that it is feasible and appropriate 5 26 in the particular rulemaking. Notice of the creation of a 5 27 negotiated rulemaking group shall be published in the Iowa 5 28 administrative bulletin. Upon establishing a negotiated 5 29 rulemaking group, the agency shall also specify a time frame 5 30 for group deliberations. 5 31 2. Unless otherwise provided by statute, the agency shall 5 32 appoint a sufficient number of members to the group so that 5 33 a fair cross section of interests and opinions regarding the 5 34 draft rule proposal is represented. One person shall be 5 35 appointed to represent the agency. The group shall select its 6 1 own chairperson and adopt its rules of procedure. All meetings 6 2 of the group shall be open to the public. A majority of the 6 3 membership constitutes a quorum. Members shall not receive 6 4 any per diem payment but shall be reimbursed for all necessary 6 5 expenses. Any vacancy shall be filled in the same manner as 6 6 the initial appointment. 6 7 3. Prior to the submission of a notice of intended action 6 8 to the administrative rules coordinator and the administrative 6 9 code editor pursuant to section 17A.4, subsection 1, the group 6 10 shall consider the terms or substance of the rule proposed 6 11 by the agency and shall attempt to reach a consensus on the 6 12 advisability of adopting the draft rule proposal. 6 13 4. If a group reaches a consensus on a draft rule proposal, 6 14 the group shall transmit to the agency a report containing the 6 15 consensus on the draft rule proposal. If the group does not 6 16 reach a consensus on a draft rule proposal within the specified 6 17 time frame, the group shall transmit to the agency a report 6 18 stating that inability to reach a consensus and specifying any 6 19 areas in which the group reached a consensus. The group may 6 20 include in a report any other information, recommendations, 6 21 or materials that the group considers appropriate. Any group 6 22 member may include as an addendum to the report additional 6 23 information, recommendations, or materials. A report issued 6 24 under this subsection shall not be considered final agency 6 25 action for purposes of judicial review. 6 26 5. Unless otherwise provided by statute, following 6 27 consideration of a draft rule proposal by a negotiated 6 28 rulemaking group, the agency may commence rulemaking as 6 29 provided in section 17A.4. The group is automatically 6 30 abolished upon the agency's adoption of the rule pursuant to 6 31 the provisions of section 17A.5. 6 32 Sec. 6. Section 17A.7, subsection 2, Code 2017, is amended 6 33 to read as follows: 6 34 2. Beginning July 1, 2012, over each five=year period of 6 35 time, an agency shall conduct an ongoing and comprehensive 7 1 review of all of the agency's rules. The goal of the review 7 2 is the identification and elimination of all rules of the 7 3 agency that are outdated, redundant,oroverbroad, ineffective, 7 4 unnecessary, inconsistent or incompatible with statute or its 7 5 own rules or those of other agencies, or otherwise undesirable. 7 6 An agency shall commence its review by developing a plan of 7 7 review in consultation with major stakeholders and constituent 7 8 groups. As part of its review, an agency shall review existing 7 9 policy and interpretive statements or similar documents to 7 10 determine whether it would be necessary or appropriate to adopt 7 11 these statements or documents as rules. 7 12 a. An agency shall establish its five=year plan for 7 13 review of its rules and publish the plan on the internet site 7 14 established pursuant to section 17A.6A. 7 15 b. An agency's plan for review shall do all of the 7 16 following: 7 17 (1) Contain a schedule that lists when the review of each 7 18 rule or group of rules will occur. 7 19 (2) State the method by which the agency will analyze 7 20 the rule under review regarding the considerations listed in 7 21 paragraph "c". 7 22 (3) Provide a means for public participation in the review 7 23 process and specify how interested persons may participate in 7 24 the review. 7 25 (4) Identify instances where the agency may require an 7 26 exception to the review requirements. 7 27 (5) Provide a process for ongoing review of rules after the 7 28 initial five=year review period has expired. 7 29 c. An agency shall analyze its rules under review by 7 30 considering all of the following: 7 31 (1) The need for the rule. 7 32 (2) The clarity of the rule. 7 33 (3) The intent and legal authority for the rule. 7 34 (4) The qualitative and quantitative benefits and costs of 7 35 the rule. 8 1 (5) The fairness of the rule. 8 2 d. When the agency completes the five=year review of the 8 3 agency's own rules, the agency shall provide a summary of 8 4 the results to the administrative rules coordinator and the 8 5 administrative rules review committee. 8 6 Sec. 7. NEW SECTION. 17A.24 Rule implementation of federal 8 7 statute, regulation, or policy. 8 8 1. Except as otherwise explicitly authorized by state law, 8 9 an agency charged with the implementation of a federal statute, 8 10 regulation, or policy shall not implement the federal statute, 8 11 regulation, or policy in a manner that exceeds the specific 8 12 requirements of the federal statute, regulation, or policy. 8 13 2. Any portion of an agency rule or policy that implements 8 14 a federal statute, regulation, or policy and that exceeds the 8 15 specific requirements of the federal statute, regulation, or 8 16 policy is automatically superseded by the specific requirements 8 17 of that federal statute, regulation, or policy. 8 18 Sec. 8. ENVIRONMENTAL REGULATION STUDY. 8 19 1. The legislative council, in consultation with the 8 20 department of natural resources, shall establish a study to 8 21 analyze the projected financial effects of current and proposed 8 22 United States environmental protection agency regulations and 8 23 Iowa department of natural resources rules on Iowa cities over 8 24 a ten=year period. 8 25 2. The study should include an analysis of projected 8 26 financial costs of such regulations and rules on a hypothetical 8 27 small Iowa community, medium=sized Iowa community, and large 8 28 Iowa community. 8 29 3. The study shall be concluded by June 30, 2018, and a 8 30 report shall be provided to the members of the general assembly 8 31 and to the governor. 8 32 EXPLANATION 8 33 The inclusion of this explanation does not constitute agreement with 8 34 the explanation's substance by the members of the general assembly. 8 35 This bill relates to the review of administrative rules and 9 1 the rulemaking process. 9 2 CITIZENS' ADVISORY COMMITTEE. The bill requires that the 9 3 administrative rules coordinator create a citizens' committee, 9 4 to advise the administrative rules coordinator on rulemaking 9 5 issues. The members of the committee shall not be paid a per 9 6 diem but shall be reimbursed for travel expenses. 9 7 RULEMAKING HEARINGS THROUGHOUT STATE. The bill requires 9 8 administrative agencies, to the extent practicable, to hold 9 9 rulemaking hearings in varied locations throughout the state 9 10 via the Iowa communications network or other electronic means. 9 11 The bill provides that a hearing must be held in a particular 9 12 city or county when 25 interested persons from that city or 9 13 county so request. 9 14 PRINCIPAL REASONS FOR AND AGAINST RULE. The bill requires 9 15 that every adopted rule must be accompanied by a concise 9 16 statement of the principal reasons for and against the rule 9 17 adopted. Under current law such a statement is only provided 9 18 on request. 9 19 JOBS IMPACT STATEMENTS. The bill requires that every 9 20 proposed rule under a notice of intended action or publication 9 21 without notice contain a jobs impact statement which outlines 9 22 the purpose and statutory authority of the rule and analyzes 9 23 and sets out in detail the impact of the proposed rule on state 9 24 agencies, local governments, the public, and the regulated 9 25 entities, including regulated businesses and self=employed 9 26 individuals affected by the rule. The statement must also 9 27 determine whether a proposed rule would have a positive 9 28 or negative impact on private sector jobs and employment 9 29 opportunities. 9 30 Commencing July 1, 2018, and every five years thereafter, 9 31 each agency shall prepare a jobs impact statement for all of 9 32 the agency's rules. 9 33 As part of this requirement, an agency is required to 9 34 takes steps to minimize the adverse impact on jobs and the 9 35 development of new employment opportunities before proposing 10 1 a rule. 10 2 The administrative rules coordinator may waive the jobs 10 3 impact statement requirement for rules filed using emergency 10 4 rulemaking procedures or if unnecessary or impractical. 10 5 NEGOTIATED RULEMAKING GROUPS. If required by statute, this 10 6 bill requires an agency to create a negotiated rulemaking group 10 7 to review draft rule proposals prior to filing a notice of 10 8 intended action pursuant to Code section 17A.4, subsection 1. 10 9 Where a statute does not require this review, the bill allows 10 10 an agency to create such a review group. Members are appointed 10 11 by the agency and the composition must adequately represent 10 12 a fair cross section of interests and opinions regarding the 10 13 rule. Once such a group is created, the agency may only 10 14 commence rulemaking after the group has considered the draft 10 15 rule proposal in question. 10 16 FIVE=YEAR CYCLE OF AGENCY REVIEW OF RULES. Current 10 17 law requires that each state agency review all of its 10 18 administrative rules on a five=year cycle. The bill provides 10 19 additional procedures and criteria for such reviews. 10 20 FEDERAL LAW IMPLEMENTATION. The bill also provides that 10 21 state implementation of a federal statute, regulation, 10 22 or policy by a state agency shall not exceed the specific 10 23 requirements of the federal statute, regulation, or 10 24 policy, except as specifically allowed by state law. Any 10 25 portion of a state rule or policy that implements a federal 10 26 statute, regulation, or policy and that exceeds the specific 10 27 requirements of the federal statute, regulation, or policy is 10 28 automatically superseded by the specific requirements of that 10 29 federal statute, regulation, or policy. 10 30 ENVIRONMENTAL RULES STUDY. The bill provides that the 10 31 legislative council, in consultation with the department of 10 32 natural resources, shall establish a study to analyze the 10 33 projected financial effects of current and proposed United 10 34 States environmental protection agency regulations and Iowa 10 35 department of natural resources rules on Iowa cities over a 11 1 10=year period. The report of the study must be completed by 11 2 June 30, 2018. LSB 1579XS (4) 87 je/rj
