Bill Amendment: IL SB2202 | 2025-2026 | 104th General Assembly
NOTE: For additional amemendments please see the Bill Drafting List
Bill Title: ACADEMIC FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION
Status: 2026-06-01 - Senate Committee Amendment No. 1 Rule 3-9(a) / Re-referred to Assignments [SB2202 Detail]
Download: Illinois-2025-SB2202-Senate_Amendment_002.html
Bill Title: ACADEMIC FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION
Status: 2026-06-01 - Senate Committee Amendment No. 1 Rule 3-9(a) / Re-referred to Assignments [SB2202 Detail]
Download: Illinois-2025-SB2202-Senate_Amendment_002.html
| |||||||
| |||||||
| 1 | AMENDMENT TO SENATE BILL 2202 | ||||||
| 2 | AMENDMENT NO. ______. Amend Senate Bill 2202 by replacing | ||||||
| 3 | everything after the enacting clause with the following: | ||||||
| 4 | "Section 5. The Public Higher Education Act is amended by | ||||||
| 5 | adding Section 8 as follows: | ||||||
| 6 | (110 ILCS 167/8 new) | ||||||
| 7 | Sec. 8. Academic freedom. | ||||||
| 8 | (a) The General Assembly finds that public institutions of | ||||||
| 9 | higher education are a public good that foster the free search | ||||||
| 10 | for truth, robust debate, and innovation that benefit this | ||||||
| 11 | State. Academic freedom is indispensable to this mission and | ||||||
| 12 | therefore warrants statutory protection. | ||||||
| 13 | (b) Every faculty member or accredited academic unit of a | ||||||
| 14 | public institution of higher education has the right to all of | ||||||
| 15 | the following: | ||||||
| 16 | (1) Freedom in teaching, including the right to select | ||||||
| |||||||
| |||||||
| 1 | pedagogical methods, course materials, and forms of | ||||||
| 2 | assessment and to present subject matter according to the | ||||||
| 3 | standards of the discipline. | ||||||
| 4 | (2) Freedom in research, including the right to | ||||||
| 5 | pursue, produce, publish, and disseminate | ||||||
| 6 | scholarship-related research without institutional or | ||||||
| 7 | governmental interference, subject only to professional | ||||||
| 8 | ethics and applicable laws. | ||||||
| 9 | (3) Freedom of expression on matters of public | ||||||
| 10 | concern, including the right to comment on institutional, | ||||||
| 11 | local, State, or federal policies, whether acting as a | ||||||
| 12 | citizen or as a member of the academic community, without | ||||||
| 13 | fear of direct or indirect retaliation. This freedom shall | ||||||
| 14 | be exercised in a manner consistent with professional | ||||||
| 15 | academic standards, institutional responsibilities, and | ||||||
| 16 | applicable laws. | ||||||
| 17 | (c) This Section may not be construed to: | ||||||
| 18 | (1) prevent this State or a public institution of | ||||||
| 19 | higher education from enacting generally applicable | ||||||
| 20 | academic standards, degree requirements, or governance | ||||||
| 21 | structures developed through established | ||||||
| 22 | shared-governance processes; | ||||||
| 23 | (2) limit compliance with federal or State civil | ||||||
| 24 | rights, health and safety, or fiduciary laws; or | ||||||
| 25 | (3) supersede any valid collective bargaining | ||||||
| 26 | agreement provisions that afford equal or greater | ||||||
| |||||||
| |||||||
| 1 | protection. | ||||||
| 2 | (d) No State officer or employee, member of a State | ||||||
| 3 | governing or coordinating board, or institutional | ||||||
| 4 | administrator may direct, coerce, or penalize any faculty | ||||||
| 5 | member of a public institution of higher education concerning | ||||||
| 6 | the specific content, viewpoint, or method of the faculty | ||||||
| 7 | member's teaching or scholarship, except as permitted under | ||||||
| 8 | subsection (c). | ||||||
| 9 | (e) The governing board of each public institution of | ||||||
| 10 | higher education shall, within 12 months after the effective | ||||||
| 11 | date of this amendatory Act of the 104th General Assembly, | ||||||
| 12 | adopt or amend institutional policies to incorporate the | ||||||
| 13 | rights and obligations set forth in this Section, in | ||||||
| 14 | consultation with recognized faculty governance bodies and, if | ||||||
| 15 | applicable, collective bargaining representatives. | ||||||
| 16 | (f) A faculty member, academic unit, or recognized faculty | ||||||
| 17 | organization aggrieved by a violation of this Section may | ||||||
| 18 | bring a civil action in the circuit court of any county in | ||||||
| 19 | which the public institution of higher education is located | ||||||
| 20 | for injunctive relief, damages, reinstatement, or reasonable | ||||||
| 21 | attorney's fees. | ||||||
| 22 | (g) This Section does not prohibit the imposition of | ||||||
| 23 | discipline for harassment, threats, or intimidation. | ||||||
| 24 | (h) This Section does not prohibit an institution from | ||||||
| 25 | adopting rules that are designed to prevent hate or violence | ||||||
| 26 | from being directed at students in a manner that denies them | ||||||
| |||||||
| |||||||
| 1 | their full participation in the educational process, so long | ||||||
| 2 | as the rules conform to standards established by the First | ||||||
| 3 | Amendment of the United States Constitution. | ||||||
| 4 | Section 10. The Board of Higher Education Act is amended | ||||||
| 5 | by adding Sections 9.47 and 9.48 as follows: | ||||||
| 6 | (110 ILCS 205/9.47 new) | ||||||
| 7 | Sec. 9.47. Academic freedom of speech policies; public | ||||||
| 8 | institutions. | ||||||
| 9 | (a) No later than one year after the effective date of this | ||||||
| 10 | amendatory Act of the 104th General Assembly, the Board shall | ||||||
| 11 | adopt rules requiring the Board of Trustees of the University | ||||||
| 12 | of Illinois, the Board of Trustees of Southern Illinois | ||||||
| 13 | University, the Board of Trustees of Chicago State University, | ||||||
| 14 | the Board of Trustees of Eastern Illinois University, the | ||||||
| 15 | Board of Trustees of Governors State University, the Board of | ||||||
| 16 | Trustees of Illinois State University, the Board of Trustees | ||||||
| 17 | of Northeastern Illinois University, the Board of Trustees of | ||||||
| 18 | Northern Illinois University, and the Board of Trustees of | ||||||
| 19 | Western Illinois University to adopt policies protecting | ||||||
| 20 | academic freedom of speech. Such policies shall include, but | ||||||
| 21 | shall not be limited to, all of the following: | ||||||
| 22 | (1) Provisions affording the right of faculty members | ||||||
| 23 | and students to freely discuss the subject matter of | ||||||
| 24 | teaching material without fear of discipline, up to and | ||||||
| |||||||
| |||||||
| 1 | including termination of a faculty member. | ||||||
| 2 | (2) Provisions affording faculty members and students | ||||||
| 3 | full freedom in research and in the publication of the | ||||||
| 4 | results of that research without fear of discipline, up to | ||||||
| 5 | and including termination of a faculty member. | ||||||
| 6 | (3) Provisions affirming the right of faculty members | ||||||
| 7 | to publicly or privately express views on university | ||||||
| 8 | policies, practices, governance, or administration without | ||||||
| 9 | fear of discipline, up to and including termination. | ||||||
| 10 | Expression on such matters constitutes speech on issues of | ||||||
| 11 | public concern, and public universities must not retaliate | ||||||
| 12 | against faculty members for engaging in such speech as | ||||||
| 13 | part of their role as public intellectuals, educators, or | ||||||
| 14 | citizens. | ||||||
| 15 | (4) Provisions affirming the right of employees to (i) | ||||||
| 16 | attend a political rally or public demonstration, as long | ||||||
| 17 | as the employees are not on duty, or (ii) write or publicly | ||||||
| 18 | comment on political issues or related topics, as long as | ||||||
| 19 | the employees are not on duty, without fear of discipline, | ||||||
| 20 | up to and including termination. | ||||||
| 21 | (b) This Section does not prohibit the imposition of | ||||||
| 22 | discipline for harassment, threats, or intimidation. | ||||||
| 23 | (c) This Section does not prohibit an institution from | ||||||
| 24 | adopting rules that are designed to prevent hate or violence | ||||||
| 25 | from being directed at students in a manner that denies them | ||||||
| 26 | their full participation in the educational process, so long | ||||||
| |||||||
| |||||||
| 1 | as the rules conform to standards established by the First | ||||||
| 2 | Amendment of the United States Constitution. | ||||||
| 3 | (110 ILCS 205/9.48 new) | ||||||
| 4 | Sec. 9.48. Academic freedom of speech plans; private | ||||||
| 5 | institutions. | ||||||
| 6 | (a) No later than one year after the effective date of this | ||||||
| 7 | amendatory Act of the 104th General Assembly, the Board shall | ||||||
| 8 | adopt and enforce rules requiring private institutions of | ||||||
| 9 | higher education to develop and implement plans related to | ||||||
| 10 | academic freedom of speech within a reasonable deadline as | ||||||
| 11 | established by the Board. Such plans shall include, but shall | ||||||
| 12 | not be limited to, all of the following: | ||||||
| 13 | (1) Provisions affording the right of faculty members | ||||||
| 14 | and students to freely discuss the subject matter of | ||||||
| 15 | teaching material without fear of discipline, up to and | ||||||
| 16 | including termination of a faculty member. | ||||||
| 17 | (2) Provisions affording faculty members and students | ||||||
| 18 | full freedom in research and in the publication of the | ||||||
| 19 | results of that research without fear of discipline, up to | ||||||
| 20 | and including termination of a faculty member. | ||||||
| 21 | (3) Provisions affirming the right of faculty members | ||||||
| 22 | to publicly or privately express views on institutional | ||||||
| 23 | policies, practices, governance, or administration without | ||||||
| 24 | fear of discipline, up to and including termination. | ||||||
| 25 | Expression on such matters constitutes speech on issues of | ||||||
| |||||||
| |||||||
| 1 | public concern, and institutions must not retaliate | ||||||
| 2 | against faculty members for engaging in such speech as | ||||||
| 3 | part of their role as public intellectuals, educators, or | ||||||
| 4 | citizens. | ||||||
| 5 | (4) Provisions affirming the right of employees to (i) | ||||||
| 6 | attend a political rally or public demonstration, as long | ||||||
| 7 | as the employees are not on duty, or (ii) write or publicly | ||||||
| 8 | comment on political issues or related topics, as long as | ||||||
| 9 | the employees are not on duty, without fear of discipline, | ||||||
| 10 | up to and including termination. | ||||||
| 11 | (b) This Section does not prohibit the imposition of | ||||||
| 12 | discipline for harassment, threats, or intimidation. | ||||||
| 13 | (c) This Section does not prohibit an institution from | ||||||
| 14 | adopting rules that are designed to prevent hate or violence | ||||||
| 15 | from being directed at students in a manner that denies them | ||||||
| 16 | their full participation in the educational process, so long | ||||||
| 17 | as the rules conform to standards established by the First | ||||||
| 18 | Amendment of the United States Constitution. | ||||||
| 19 | (d) This Section does not apply to a private postsecondary | ||||||
| 20 | educational institution that is controlled by a religious | ||||||
| 21 | organization to the extent that the application of this | ||||||
| 22 | Section is inconsistent with the religious tenets of that | ||||||
| 23 | organization. | ||||||
| 24 | Section 15. The Public Community College Act is amended by | ||||||
| 25 | changing Section 2-12 and by adding Section 3-22.4 as follows: | ||||||
| |||||||
| |||||||
| 1 | (110 ILCS 805/2-12) (from Ch. 122, par. 102-12) | ||||||
| 2 | Sec. 2-12. The State Board shall have the power and it | ||||||
| 3 | shall be its duty: | ||||||
| 4 | (a) To provide statewide planning for community | ||||||
| 5 | colleges as institutions of higher education and to | ||||||
| 6 | coordinate the programs, services and activities of all | ||||||
| 7 | community colleges in the State so as to encourage and | ||||||
| 8 | establish a system of locally initiated and administered | ||||||
| 9 | comprehensive community colleges. | ||||||
| 10 | (b) To organize and conduct feasibility surveys for | ||||||
| 11 | new community colleges or for the inclusion of existing | ||||||
| 12 | institutions as community colleges and the locating of new | ||||||
| 13 | institutions. | ||||||
| 14 | (c) (Blank). | ||||||
| 15 | (c-5) In collaboration with the community colleges, to | ||||||
| 16 | furnish information for State and federal accountability | ||||||
| 17 | purposes, promote student and institutional improvement, | ||||||
| 18 | and meet research needs. | ||||||
| 19 | (d) To cooperate with the community colleges in | ||||||
| 20 | collecting and maintaining student characteristics, | ||||||
| 21 | enrollment and completion data, faculty and staff | ||||||
| 22 | characteristics, financial data, admission standards, | ||||||
| 23 | facility data, and any other issues facing community | ||||||
| 24 | colleges. | ||||||
| 25 | (e) To enter into contracts with other governmental | ||||||
| |||||||
| |||||||
| 1 | agencies and eligible providers, such as local educational | ||||||
| 2 | agencies, community-based organizations of demonstrated | ||||||
| 3 | effectiveness, volunteer literacy organizations of | ||||||
| 4 | demonstrated effectiveness, institutions of higher | ||||||
| 5 | education, public and private nonprofit agencies, | ||||||
| 6 | libraries, and public housing authorities; to accept | ||||||
| 7 | federal funds and to plan with other State agencies when | ||||||
| 8 | appropriate for the allocation of such federal funds for | ||||||
| 9 | instructional programs and student services including such | ||||||
| 10 | funds for adult education and literacy, vocational and | ||||||
| 11 | career and technical education, and retraining as may be | ||||||
| 12 | allocated by state and federal agencies for the aid of | ||||||
| 13 | community colleges. To receive, receipt for, hold in | ||||||
| 14 | trust, expend and administer, for all purposes of this | ||||||
| 15 | Act, funds and other aid made available by the federal | ||||||
| 16 | government or by other agencies public or private, subject | ||||||
| 17 | to appropriation by the General Assembly. The changes to | ||||||
| 18 | this subdivision (e) made by Public Act 91-830 apply on | ||||||
| 19 | and after July 1, 2001. | ||||||
| 20 | (f) To determine efficient and adequate standards for | ||||||
| 21 | community colleges for the physical plant, heating, | ||||||
| 22 | lighting, ventilation, sanitation, safety, equipment and | ||||||
| 23 | supplies, instruction and teaching, curriculum, library, | ||||||
| 24 | operation, maintenance, and administration and | ||||||
| 25 | supervision. | ||||||
| 26 | (g) To determine the standards for establishment of | ||||||
| |||||||
| |||||||
| 1 | community colleges and the proper location of the site in | ||||||
| 2 | relation to existing institutions of higher education | ||||||
| 3 | offering academic, occupational and technical training | ||||||
| 4 | curricula, possible enrollment, assessed valuation, | ||||||
| 5 | industrial, business, agricultural, and other conditions | ||||||
| 6 | reflecting educational needs in the area to be served; | ||||||
| 7 | however, no community college may be considered as being | ||||||
| 8 | recognized nor may the establishment of any community | ||||||
| 9 | college be authorized in any district which shall be | ||||||
| 10 | deemed inadequate for the maintenance, in accordance with | ||||||
| 11 | the desirable standards thus determined, of a community | ||||||
| 12 | college offering the basic subjects of general education | ||||||
| 13 | and suitable vocational and semiprofessional and technical | ||||||
| 14 | curricula. | ||||||
| 15 | (h) To approve or disapprove new units of instruction, | ||||||
| 16 | research or public service as defined in Section 3-25.1 of | ||||||
| 17 | this Act submitted by the boards of trustees of the | ||||||
| 18 | respective community college districts of this State. The | ||||||
| 19 | State Board may discontinue programs which fail to reflect | ||||||
| 20 | the educational needs of the area being served. The | ||||||
| 21 | community college district shall be granted 60 days | ||||||
| 22 | following the State Board staff recommendation and prior | ||||||
| 23 | to the State Board's action to respond to concerns | ||||||
| 24 | regarding the program in question. If the State Board acts | ||||||
| 25 | to abolish a community college program, the community | ||||||
| 26 | college district has a right to appeal the decision in | ||||||
| |||||||
| |||||||
| 1 | accordance with administrative rules promulgated by the | ||||||
| 2 | State Board under the provisions of the Illinois | ||||||
| 3 | Administrative Procedure Act. | ||||||
| 4 | (i) To review and approve or disapprove any contract | ||||||
| 5 | or agreement that community colleges enter into with any | ||||||
| 6 | organization, association, educational institution, or | ||||||
| 7 | government agency to provide educational services for | ||||||
| 8 | academic credit. The State Board is authorized to monitor | ||||||
| 9 | performance under any contract or agreement that is | ||||||
| 10 | approved by the State Board. If the State Board does not | ||||||
| 11 | approve a particular contract or agreement, the community | ||||||
| 12 | college district has a right to appeal the decision in | ||||||
| 13 | accordance with administrative rules promulgated by the | ||||||
| 14 | State Board under the provisions of the Illinois | ||||||
| 15 | Administrative Procedure Act. Nothing in this subdivision | ||||||
| 16 | (i) shall be interpreted as applying to collective | ||||||
| 17 | bargaining agreements with any labor organization. | ||||||
| 18 | (j) To establish guidelines regarding sabbatical | ||||||
| 19 | leaves. | ||||||
| 20 | (k) (Blank). | ||||||
| 21 | (l) (Blank). | ||||||
| 22 | (m) (Blank). | ||||||
| 23 | (n) To create and participate in the conduct and | ||||||
| 24 | operation of any corporation, joint venture, partnership, | ||||||
| 25 | association, or other organizational entity that has the | ||||||
| 26 | power: (i) to acquire land, buildings, and other capital | ||||||
| |||||||
| |||||||
| 1 | equipment for the use and benefit of the community | ||||||
| 2 | colleges or their students; (ii) to accept gifts and make | ||||||
| 3 | grants for the use and benefit of the community colleges | ||||||
| 4 | or their students; (iii) to aid in the instruction and | ||||||
| 5 | education of students of community colleges; and (iv) to | ||||||
| 6 | promote activities to acquaint members of the community | ||||||
| 7 | with the facilities of the various community colleges. | ||||||
| 8 | (o) To ensure the effective teaching of adult learners | ||||||
| 9 | and to prepare them for success in employment and lifelong | ||||||
| 10 | learning by administering a network of providers, | ||||||
| 11 | programs, and services to provide classes for the | ||||||
| 12 | instruction of those individuals who (i) are 16 years of | ||||||
| 13 | age or older, are not enrolled or required to be enrolled | ||||||
| 14 | in a secondary school under State law, and are | ||||||
| 15 | basic-skills deficient, (ii) do not have a secondary | ||||||
| 16 | school diploma or its recognized equivalent and have not | ||||||
| 17 | achieved an equivalent level of education, or (iii) are an | ||||||
| 18 | English language learner. Classes in adult education may | ||||||
| 19 | include adult basic education, adult secondary and high | ||||||
| 20 | school equivalency testing education, high school credit, | ||||||
| 21 | literacy, English language acquisition, integrated | ||||||
| 22 | education and training in coordination with vocational | ||||||
| 23 | skills training, and any other instruction designed to | ||||||
| 24 | prepare adult students to function successfully in society | ||||||
| 25 | and to experience success in postsecondary education and | ||||||
| 26 | employment. | ||||||
| |||||||
| |||||||
| 1 | (p) To supervise the administration of adult education | ||||||
| 2 | and literacy programs, to establish the standards for such | ||||||
| 3 | courses of instruction and supervise the administration | ||||||
| 4 | thereof, to contract with other State and local agencies | ||||||
| 5 | and eligible providers of demonstrated effectiveness, such | ||||||
| 6 | as local educational agencies, community-based | ||||||
| 7 | organizations, volunteer literacy organizations, | ||||||
| 8 | institutions of higher education, public and private | ||||||
| 9 | nonprofit agencies, libraries, public housing authorities, | ||||||
| 10 | and nonprofit institutions for the purpose of promoting | ||||||
| 11 | and establishing classes for instruction under these | ||||||
| 12 | programs, to contract with other State and local agencies | ||||||
| 13 | to accept and expend appropriations for educational | ||||||
| 14 | purposes to reimburse local eligible providers for the | ||||||
| 15 | cost of these programs, and to establish an advisory | ||||||
| 16 | council consisting of all categories of eligible | ||||||
| 17 | providers; agency partners, such as the State Board of | ||||||
| 18 | Education, the Department of Human Services, the | ||||||
| 19 | Department of Employment Security, the Department of | ||||||
| 20 | Commerce and Economic Opportunity, and the Secretary of | ||||||
| 21 | State literacy program; and other stakeholders to | ||||||
| 22 | identify, deliberate, and make recommendations to the | ||||||
| 23 | State Board on adult education policy and priorities. The | ||||||
| 24 | State Board shall support statewide geographic | ||||||
| 25 | distribution; diversity of eligible providers; and the | ||||||
| 26 | adequacy, stability, and predictability of funding so as | ||||||
| |||||||
| |||||||
| 1 | not to disrupt or diminish, but rather to enhance, adult | ||||||
| 2 | education and literacy services. | ||||||
| 3 | (q) No later than one year after the effective date of | ||||||
| 4 | this amendatory Act of the 104th General Assembly, to | ||||||
| 5 | adopt and enforce rules that ensure that all faculty | ||||||
| 6 | members of a community college are entitled to freedom in | ||||||
| 7 | the classroom in discussing their subject, including | ||||||
| 8 | ensuring that such faculty members have the right to | ||||||
| 9 | introduce into their teaching matters related to the | ||||||
| 10 | faculty members' subject or the education of their | ||||||
| 11 | students in that subject within the discourse of the | ||||||
| 12 | faculty members' discipline. Such freedom shall be | ||||||
| 13 | extended within the confines of course outcomes, degree or | ||||||
| 14 | program requirements, and accreditation requirements. | ||||||
| 15 | (r) No later than one year after the effective date of | ||||||
| 16 | this amendatory Act of the 104th General Assembly, to | ||||||
| 17 | adopt and enforce rules that ensure that faculty members | ||||||
| 18 | and students at a community college are entitled to full | ||||||
| 19 | freedom in research and in the publication of the results | ||||||
| 20 | of that research. | ||||||
| 21 | (Source: P.A. 103-940, eff. 8-9-24.) | ||||||
| 22 | (110 ILCS 805/3-22.4 new) | ||||||
| 23 | Sec. 3-22.4. Academic freedom of speech. | ||||||
| 24 | (a) No later than one year after the effective date of this | ||||||
| 25 | amendatory Act of the 104th General Assembly, to adopt and | ||||||
| |||||||
| |||||||
| 1 | enforce all necessary rules that are at least as stringent as | ||||||
| 2 | those established by the State Board pursuant to subsections | ||||||
| 3 | (q) and (r) of Section 2-12 to ensure that: | ||||||
| 4 | (1) all faculty members are entitled to freedom in the | ||||||
| 5 | classroom in discussing their subject, including ensuring | ||||||
| 6 | that such faculty members have the right to introduce into | ||||||
| 7 | their teaching matters related to the faculty members' | ||||||
| 8 | subject or the education of their students in that subject | ||||||
| 9 | within the discourse of the faculty members' discipline; | ||||||
| 10 | such freedom shall be extended within the confines of | ||||||
| 11 | course outcomes, degree or program requirements, and | ||||||
| 12 | accreditation requirements; | ||||||
| 13 | (2) all faculty members and students are entitled to | ||||||
| 14 | full freedom in research and in the publication of the | ||||||
| 15 | results of that research; | ||||||
| 16 | (3) all faculty members are entitled to publicly or | ||||||
| 17 | privately express views on community college policies, | ||||||
| 18 | practices, governance, or administration without fear of | ||||||
| 19 | discipline, up to and including termination. Expression on | ||||||
| 20 | such matters constitutes speech on issues of public | ||||||
| 21 | concern, and community colleges must not retaliate against | ||||||
| 22 | faculty members for engaging in such speech as part of | ||||||
| 23 | their role as public intellectuals, educators, or | ||||||
| 24 | citizens; and | ||||||
| 25 | (4) all employees are entitled to (i) attend a | ||||||
| 26 | political rally or public demonstration, as long as the | ||||||
| |||||||
| |||||||
| 1 | employees are not on duty, or (ii) write or publicly | ||||||
| 2 | comment on political issues or related topics, as long as | ||||||
| 3 | the employees are not on duty, without fear of discipline, | ||||||
| 4 | up to and including termination. | ||||||
| 5 | (b) This Section does not prohibit the imposition of | ||||||
| 6 | discipline for harassment, threats, or intimidation. | ||||||
| 7 | (c) This Section does not prohibit an institution from | ||||||
| 8 | adopting rules that are designed to prevent hate violence from | ||||||
| 9 | being directed at students in a manner that denies them their | ||||||
| 10 | full participation in the educational process, so long as the | ||||||
| 11 | rules conform to standards established by the First Amendment | ||||||
| 12 | of the United States Constitution.". | ||||||
