Bill Text: TX SB690 | 2021-2022 | 87th Legislature | Introduced

---

Bill Title: Relating to remotely conducting court proceedings in this state.

Spectrum: Partisan Bill (Democrat 2-0)

Status: (Introduced - Dead) 2021-04-22 - Left pending in committee [SB690 Detail]

Download: Texas-2021-SB690-Introduced.html

---

By: Zaffirini S.B. No. 690

A BILL TO BE ENTITLED
AN ACT
relating to remotely conducting court proceedings in this state.
BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF TEXAS:
ARTICLE 1. REMOTE PROCEEDINGS
SECTION 1.001. Section 21.009, Government Code, is amended
by adding Subdivision (5) to read as follows:
(5) "Remote proceeding" means a proceeding before a
court in which one or more of the participants, including a judge,
party, attorney, witness, court reporter, juror, or other
individual, attends the proceeding remotely through the use of
technology and the Internet.
SECTION 1.002. Chapter 21, Government Code, is amended by
adding Section 21.013 to read as follows:
Sec. 21.013. OPTION FOR REMOTE PROCEEDING. (a)
Notwithstanding any other law, a court in this state on the court's
own motion or on the motion of any party may:
(1) conduct a hearing or other proceeding as a remote
proceeding without the consent of the parties unless the United
States Constitution or Texas Constitution requires consent; and
(2) allow or require a judge, party, attorney,
witness, court reporter, juror, or any other individual to
participate in a remote proceeding, including a deposition,
hearing, trial, or other proceeding.
(b) In any criminal proceeding that under the United States
Constitution or Texas Constitution requires the consent of the
parties for the proceeding to be conducted as a remote proceeding,
the prosecutor and defendant must each consent for the proceeding
to be conducted as a remote proceeding. If the prosecutor or
defendant does not consent, the proceeding may not be held as a
remote proceeding.
(c) For a jury trial that is to be conducted as a remote
proceeding, a court shall:
(1) consider on the record any motion or objection
related to proceeding with the trial not later than the seventh day
before the trial date, except that if the motion or objection is
made later than the seventh day before the trial date, the court
must consider the motion or objection on the record as soon as
practicable; and
(2) ensure all prospective jurors have access to the
technology necessary to participate in the remote proceeding.
(d) If a remote proceeding is conducted away from the
court's usual location, the court must provide reasonable notice to
the public and an opportunity to observe the proceeding.
(e) The Office of Court Administration of the Texas Judicial
System shall provide guidance and assistance to the extent possible
to a court conducting a remote proceeding.
(f) For purposes of any law requiring notice or citation of
the time and place for a proceeding, notice of the remote means by
which the proceeding will be conducted and the method for accessing
the proceeding through that remote means constitutes notice of the
place for the proceeding.
ARTICLE 2. CONFORMING CHANGES
SECTION 2.001. Section 30.012(a), Civil Practice and
Remedies Code, is amended to read as follows:
(a) Subject [With the agreement of the parties, and subject]
to Section 21.013, Government Code [Subsection (b)], a trial judge
may order that a hearing of a preliminary matter or witness
testimony at trial may be conducted by electronic means, including
satellite transmission, closed-circuit television transmission, or
any other method of two-way electronic communication that is
available to the parties, approved by the court, and capable of
visually and audibly recording the proceedings.
SECTION 2.002. Article 27.18(a), Code of Criminal
Procedure, is amended to read as follows:
(a) Subject to Section 21.013, Government Code, and
notwithstanding [Notwithstanding] any provision of this code
requiring that a plea or a waiver of a defendant's right be made in
open court, a court may accept the plea or waiver by videoconference
to the court if:
(1) [the defendant and the attorney representing the
state file with the court written consent to the use of
videoconference;
[(2)] the videoconference provides for a
simultaneous, compressed full motion video, and interactive
communication of image and sound between the judge, the attorney
representing the state, the defendant, and the defendant's
attorney; and
(2) [(3)] on request of the defendant, the defendant
and the defendant's attorney are able to communicate privately
without being recorded or heard by the judge or the attorney
representing the state.
SECTION 2.003. Section 53.102(a), Estates Code, is amended
to read as follows:
(a) If a judge is unable to designate the time and place, or
the time and remote means in accordance with Section 21.013,
Government Code, for hearing a probate matter pending in the
judge's court because the judge [is absent from the county seat or]
is on vacation, disqualified, ill, or deceased, the county clerk of
the county in which the matter is pending may:
(1) designate the time and place, or the time and
remote means in accordance with Section 21.013, Government Code,
for the hearing;
(2) enter the setting on the judge's docket; and
(3) certify on the docket the reason that the judge is
not acting to set the hearing.
SECTION 2.004. Section 1053.102(a), Estates Code, is
amended to read as follows:
(a) If a judge is unable to designate the time and place, or
the time and remote means in accordance with Section 21.013,
Government Code, for hearing a guardianship proceeding pending in
the judge's court because the judge [is absent from the county seat
or] is on vacation, disqualified, ill, or deceased, the county
clerk of the county in which the proceeding is pending may:
(1) designate the time and place, or the time and
remote means in accordance with Section 21.013, Government Code,
for the hearing;
(2) enter the setting on the judge's docket; and
(3) certify on the docket the reason that the judge is
not acting to set the hearing.
SECTION 2.005. Section 1055.053, Estates Code, is amended
to read as follows:
Sec. 1055.053. LOCATION OR MEANS OF HEARING. (a) Except as
provided by Subsection (b), the judge may hold a hearing on a
guardianship proceeding involving an adult ward or adult proposed
ward at any suitable location in the county in which the
guardianship proceeding is pending or as a remote proceeding as
authorized by Section 21.013, Government Code. The hearing should
be held in a physical setting that is not likely to have a harmful
effect on the ward or proposed ward.
(b) On the request of the adult proposed ward, the adult
ward, or the attorney of the proposed ward or ward, the hearing may
not be held under the authority of this section at a place other
than the courthouse except as authorized by Section 21.013,
Government Code.
SECTION 2.006. Section 51.115(c), Family Code, is amended
to read as follows:
(c) A person required under this section to attend a hearing
is entitled to reasonable written or oral notice that includes a
statement of the location of, subject to Section 21.013, Government
Code, and the [place,] date[,] and time of, the hearing and that the
attendance of the person is required. The notice may be included
with or attached to any other notice required by this chapter to be
given the person. Separate notice is not required for a disposition
hearing that convenes on the adjournment of an adjudication
hearing. If a person required under this section fails to attend a
hearing, the juvenile court may proceed with the hearing.
SECTION 2.007. Section 54.012(a), Family Code, is amended
to read as follows:
(a) Subject to Section 21.013, Government Code, a [A]
detention hearing under Section 54.01 may be held using interactive
video equipment if[:
[(1) the child and the child's attorney agree to the
video hearing; and
[(2)] the parties to the proceeding have the
opportunity to cross-examine witnesses.
SECTION 2.008. Sections 22.202(a) and (g), Government Code,
are amended to read as follows:
(a) Subject to Section 21.013, the [The] Court of Appeals
for the First Court of Appeals District shall be held in the City of
Houston.
(g) The First Court of Appeals may transact its business in
any county in the First Court of Appeals District as the court
determines necessary and convenient or as provided by Section
21.013.
SECTION 2.009. Sections 22.203(a) and (b), Government Code,
are amended to read as follows:
(a) Subject to Section 21.013, the [The] Court of Appeals
for the Second Court of Appeals District shall be held in the City
of Fort Worth.
(b) The court may transact its business in any county in the
district as the court determines is necessary or convenient or as
provided by Section 21.013.
SECTION 2.010. Sections 22.204(a) and (b), Government Code,
are amended to read as follows:
(a) Subject to Section 21.013, the [The] Court of Appeals
for the Third Court of Appeals District shall be held in the City of
Austin.
(b) The court may transact its business:
(1) at the county seat of any of the counties within
its district as the court determines is necessary and convenient,
except that all cases originating in Travis County shall be heard
and transacted in that county, subject to Subdivision (2); or
(2) as provided by Section 21.013.
SECTION 2.011. Section 22.205, Government Code, is amended
to read as follows:
Sec. 22.205. FOURTH COURT OF APPEALS. (a) Subject to
Section 21.013, the [The] Court of Appeals for the Fourth Court of
Appeals District shall be held in the City of San Antonio.
(b) The court may transact its business:
(1) at the county seat of any of the counties within
its district, as the court determines is necessary and convenient,
except that all cases originating in Bexar County that the court
hears shall be heard and transacted in that county, subject to
Subdivision (2); or
(2) as provided by Section 21.013.
SECTION 2.012. Sections 22.206(a) and (b), Government Code,
are amended to read as follows:
(a) Subject to Section 21.013, the [The] Court of Appeals
for the Fifth Court of Appeals District shall be primarily held in
the City of Dallas.
(b) The court may transact its business in any county in the
district as the court determines is necessary and convenient or as
provided by Section 21.013.
SECTION 2.013. Section 22.207, Government Code, is amended
to read as follows:
Sec. 22.207. SIXTH COURT OF APPEALS. (a) Subject to
Section 21.013, the [The] Court of Appeals for the Sixth Court of
Appeals District shall be held in the City of Texarkana.
(b) The court may transact its business:
(1) in the City of Texarkana or the county seat of any
county in the district as the court determines is necessary or
convenient, except that all cases originating in Bowie County shall
be heard and transacted in the City of Texarkana, subject to
Subdivision (2); or
(2) as provided by Section 21.013.
SECTION 2.014. Section 22.208, Government Code, is amended
to read as follows:
Sec. 22.208. SEVENTH COURT OF APPEALS. Subject to Section
21.013, the [The] Court of Appeals for the Seventh Court of Appeals
District shall be held in the City of Amarillo.
SECTION 2.015. Section 22.209, Government Code, is amended
to read as follows:
Sec. 22.209. EIGHTH COURT OF APPEALS. (a) Subject to
Section 21.013, the [The] Court of Appeals for the Eighth Court of
Appeals District shall be held in the City of El Paso.
(b) The court may transact its business:
(1) at the county seat of any county in the district as
the court determines is necessary and convenient, except all cases
originating in El Paso County shall be heard and transacted in that
county, subject to Subdivision (2); or
(2) as provided by Section 21.013.
SECTION 2.016. Sections 22.210(a) and (c), Government Code,
are amended to read as follows:
(a) Subject to Section 21.013, the [The] Court of Appeals
for the Ninth Court of Appeals District shall be held in the City of
Beaumont.
(c) The court may transact its business in the City of
Beaumont or the county seat of any county in the district as the
court determines is necessary or convenient, or as provided by
Section 21.013.
SECTION 2.017. Section 22.211(a), Government Code, is
amended to read as follows:
(a) Subject to Section 21.013, the [The] Court of Appeals
for the Tenth Court of Appeals District shall be held in the City of
Waco or in the county seat of any county located within the Tenth
Court of Appeals District.
SECTION 2.018. Sections 22.212(a) and (c), Government Code,
are amended to read as follows:
(a) Subject to Section 21.013, the [The] Court of Appeals
for the Eleventh Court of Appeals District shall be held in the City
of Eastland.
(c) The court may transact its business in the City of
Eastland or in any county in the district as the court determines is
necessary or convenient, or as provided by Section 21.013.
SECTION 2.019. Sections 22.213(a) and (c), Government Code,
are amended to read as follows:
(a) Subject to Section 21.013, the [The] Court of Appeals
for the Twelfth Court of Appeals District shall be held in the City
of Tyler.
(c) The court may transact its business:
(1) in the City of Tyler or at the county seat of any
county in the district as the court determines is necessary or
convenient, except that all cases originating in Smith County shall
be heard and transacted in the City of Tyler, subject to Subdivision
(2); or
(2) as provided by Section 21.013.
SECTION 2.020. Sections 22.214(a) and (c), Government Code,
are amended to read as follows:
(a) Subject to Section 21.013, the [The] Court of Appeals
for the Thirteenth Court of Appeals District shall be held in the
City of Corpus Christi and the City of Edinburg.
(c) The court may transact its business:
(1) subject to Subdivision (2), at the county seat of
any county in the district as the court determines is necessary and
convenient, except that:
(A) [(1)] all cases originating in Nueces County
shall be heard and transacted in Nueces County, subject to
Subdivision (2); and
(B) [(2)] all cases originating in Cameron,
Hidalgo, or Willacy County shall be heard and transacted in
Cameron, Hidalgo, or Willacy County, subject to Subdivision (2); or
(2) as provided by Section 21.013.
SECTION 2.021. Sections 22.215(a) and (c), Government Code,
are amended to read as follows:
(a) Subject to Section 21.013, the [The] Court of Appeals
for the Fourteenth Court of Appeals District shall be held in the
City of Houston.
(c) The Fourteenth Court of Appeals may transact its
business in any county in the First Court of Appeals District as the
court determines necessary and convenient or as provided by Section
21.013.
SECTION 2.022. Subchapter A, Chapter 24, Government Code,
is amended by adding Section 24.0301 to read as follows:
Sec. 24.0301. REMOTE PROCEEDINGS. Notwithstanding Section
24.030 or any other provision of this chapter requiring a district
court to sit and conduct the court's proceedings in a specified
county or municipality, a district court may conduct the court's
proceedings as provided by Section 21.013.
SECTION 2.023. Section 25.0001(a), Government Code, is
amended to read as follows:
(a) This subchapter applies to each statutory county
court in this state. Except as provided by Section 25.00105, if
[If] a provision of this subchapter conflicts with a specific
provision for a particular court or county, the specific provision
controls.
SECTION 2.024. Subchapter A, Chapter 25, Government Code,
is amended by adding Section 25.00105 to read as follows:
Sec. 25.00105. REMOTE PROCEEDINGS. Notwithstanding any
other law, including a specific provision in this chapter for a
particular court or county that requires a statutory county court
to sit and conduct the court's proceedings at the county seat, a
statutory county court may conduct the court's proceedings as
provided by Section 21.013.
SECTION 2.025. Subchapter B, Chapter 25, Government Code,
is amended by adding Section 25.00305 to read as follows:
Sec. 25.00305. REMOTE PROCEEDINGS. Notwithstanding any
other law, including a specific provision in this chapter for a
particular court or county that requires a statutory probate court
to sit and conduct the court's proceedings at the county seat, a
statutory probate court may conduct the court's proceedings as
provided by Section 21.013.
SECTION 2.026. Section 26.002(c), Government Code, is
amended to read as follows:
(c) All terms of court must be held at the county seat,
except that the court may conduct the court's proceedings as
provided by Section 21.013.
SECTION 2.027. Section 27.051(b), Government Code, is
amended to read as follows:
(b) Subject to Section 21.013:
(1) each [Each] justice shall hold the regular term of
court at the justice's office at times prescribed by the
commissioners court; and
(2) the[. The] commissioners court shall set the time
and place for holding justice court.
SECTION 2.028. Section 30.00001(c), Government Code, is
amended to read as follows:
(c) Except as provided by Section 30.00138(b)(2), if [If] a
provision of this subchapter conflicts with a specific provision
for a particular municipality, the specific provision controls.
SECTION 2.029. Section 30.00138, Government Code, is
amended to read as follows:
Sec. 30.00138. TERM OF COURT. (a) The appellate court may
sit for the transaction of business at any time during the year, and
each term begins and ends with the calendar year.
(b) The appellate court may:
(1) use the city council chambers or other appropriate
location as its courtroom for argument of cases and other court
matters; or
(2) conduct proceedings as provided by Section 21.013.
SECTION 2.030. Sections 573.012(a) and (h), Health and
Safety Code, are amended to read as follows:
(a) Except as provided by Subsection (h) and Section 21.013,
Government Code, an applicant for emergency detention must present
the application personally to a judge or magistrate. The judge or
magistrate shall examine the application and may interview the
applicant. Except as provided by Subsection (g), the judge of a
court with probate jurisdiction by administrative order may provide
that the application must be:
(1) presented personally to the court; or
(2) retained by court staff and presented to another
judge or magistrate as soon as is practicable if the judge of the
court is not available at the time the application is presented.
(h) A judge or magistrate may permit an applicant [who is a
physician] to present an application by:
(1) e-mail with the application attached as a secure
document in a portable document format (PDF); or
(2) subject to Section 21.013, Government
Code, secure electronic means, including:
(A) satellite transmission;
(B) closed-circuit television transmission; or
(C) any other method of two-way electronic
communication that:
(i) is secure;
(ii) is available to the judge or
magistrate; and
(iii) provides for a simultaneous,
compressed full-motion video and interactive communication of
image and sound between the judge or magistrate and the applicant.
SECTION 2.031. Sections 574.031(a) and (b), Health and
Safety Code, are amended to read as follows:
(a) Except as provided by Subsection (b), the judge may hold
a hearing on an application for court-ordered mental health
services at any suitable location in the county or as a remote
proceeding as authorized by Section 21.013, Government Code. The
hearing should be held in a physical setting that is not likely to
have a harmful effect on the proposed patient.
(b) On the request of the proposed patient or the proposed
patient's attorney the hearing on the application shall be held in
the county courthouse except as authorized by Section 21.013,
Government Code.
SECTION 2.032. Section 574.203(a), Health and Safety Code,
is amended to read as follows:
(a) Subject to Section 21.013, Government Code, a [A]
hearing may be conducted in accordance with this chapter but
conducted by secure electronic means, including satellite
transmission, closed-circuit television transmission, or any other
method of two-way electronic communication that is secure,
available to the parties, approved by the court, and capable of
visually and audibly recording the proceedings, if:
(1) [written consent to the use of a secure electronic
communication method for the hearing is filed with the court by:
[(A) the proposed patient or the attorney
representing the proposed patient; and
[(B) the county or district attorney, as
appropriate;
[(2)] the secure electronic communication method
provides for a simultaneous, compressed full-motion video, and
interactive communication of image and sound among the judge or
associate judge, the county or district attorney, the attorney
representing the proposed patient, and the proposed patient; and
(2) [(3)] on request of the proposed patient or the
attorney representing the proposed patient, the proposed patient
and the attorney can communicate privately without being recorded
or heard by the judge or associate judge or by the county or
district attorney.
SECTION 2.033. Section 292.001(d), Local Government Code,
is amended to read as follows:
(d) A justice of the peace court may not be housed or
conducted in a building located outside the court's precinct except
as provided by Section 21.013, 27.051(f), or 27.0515, Government
Code, or unless the justice of the peace court is situated in the
county courthouse in a county with a population of at least 275,000
persons but no more than 285,000 persons.
SECTION 2.034. The following provisions are repealed:
(1) Section 30.012(b), Civil Practice and Remedies
Code; and
(2) Section 54.012(b), Family Code.
ARTICLE 3. EFFECTIVE DATE
SECTION 3.001. This Act takes effect September 1, 2021.