Bill Text: NY S06177 | 2017-2018 | General Assembly | Amended


Bill Title: Regulates the use and terms of rent to own leases in and outside of manufactured home parks.

Spectrum: Partisan Bill (Republican 1-0)

Status: (Engrossed - Dead) 2018-06-20 - COMMITTED TO RULES [S06177 Detail]

Download: New_York-2017-S06177-Amended.html


                STATE OF NEW YORK
        ________________________________________________________________________
                                         6177--A
                               2017-2018 Regular Sessions
                    IN SENATE
                                      May 11, 2017
                                       ___________
        Introduced  by  Sen.  LITTLE -- read twice and ordered printed, and when
          printed to be committed  to  the  Committee  on  Local  Government  --
          committee discharged and said bill committed to the Committee on Hous-
          ing, Construction and Community Development -- reported favorably from
          said  committee and committed to the Committee on Finance -- committee
          discharged, bill amended, ordered reprinted as amended and recommitted
          to said committee
        AN ACT to amend the real property law,  in  relation  to  lease  to  own
          contracts in manufactured home communities
          The  People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assem-
        bly, do enact as follows:
     1    Section 1. Section 233 of the real property law is amended by adding a
     2  new subdivision y to read as follows:
     3    y. Lease to own contracts. 1. Definitions. For purposes of this subdi-
     4  vision:
     5    (a) "Commercial communication" shall mean any written or  oral  state-
     6  ment,  illustration  or  depiction,  whether  in  English  or  any other
     7  language, that is designed to  effect  a  sale  or  create  interest  in
     8  purchasing goods or services, whether it appears on or in a label, pack-
     9  age,  package  insert,  radio,  television,  cable television, brochure,
    10  newspaper, magazine, pamphlet, leaflet, circular, mailer,  book  insert,
    11  free  standing  insert,  letter,  catalogue,  poster,  chart, billboard,
    12  public transit card, point  of  purchase  display,  film,  slide,  audio
    13  program  transmitted  over  a  telephone  system,  telemarketing script,
    14  on-hold script, upsell script, training materials provided  to  telemar-
    15  keting  firms,  program-length commercial ("infomercial"), the internet,
    16  cellular network, or any other medium. Promotional materials and  items,
    17  and web pages shall be included in the term commercial communication.
    18    (b)  "Lease  to own contract" shall mean an agreement where a manufac-
    19  tured home park owner or operator, or a lessor, which may be (i) another
    20  entity certified as a manufactured home  retailer  pursuant  to  article
         EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
                              [ ] is old law to be omitted.
                                                                   LBD11654-03-7

        S. 6177--A                          2
     1  twenty-one-B  of  the executive law, or (ii) a landowner, enters into an
     2  agreement with a manufactured home tenant whereby the manufactured  home
     3  tenant leases a home located in a manufactured home park and, whether in
     4  the  lease  to  own agreement or in a separate agreement, leases the lot
     5  upon which the  home  is  located,  and  the  manufactured  home  tenant
     6  receives  an  option  to  purchase  the manufactured or mobile home upon
     7  payment of specified payments over a specified period of time, and  upon
     8  the  expiration  of  the  time  period,  and  payment  of  the specified
     9  payments, the manufactured home tenant obtains title  and  ownership  of
    10  the home.
    11    (c)  "Lease  to own payments" shall mean the periodic amounts required
    12  to be paid over the duration of the lease  to  own  contract,  over  and
    13  above  any  payments required for rental of the lot upon which the manu-
    14  factured home is located. Lease to own payments shall also  include  the
    15  amount required to be paid at the end of the term.
    16    (d)  "Lessee"  shall  mean  a manufactured home community owner or any
    17  other person, corporation, association, or other legal entity who leases
    18  a manufactured or mobile home subject to a lease to own contract.
    19    (e) "Lessor" shall mean any person, corporation,  association  or  any
    20  other legal entity who leases a manufactured or mobile home subject to a
    21  lease to own contract.
    22    (f)  "Terms"  means any of the fees, costs, obligations, or character-
    23  istics of or associated with the lease to own option.
    24    2. Requirements for lease to own contracts:
    25    (a) on and after the effective date of this subdivision,  no  manufac-
    26  tured  home  park owner or operator, or lessor, shall enter into a lease
    27  to own contract except in accordance with the provisions of this  subdi-
    28  vision;
    29    (b)  on  or  after the effective date of this subdivision, no manufac-
    30  tured home park owner or operator or lessor shall offer a lease  to  own
    31  contract unless the manufactured home park owner or operator, or lessor,
    32  has  complied  with the provisions of this subparagraph to establish the
    33  ownership of the home that is to be transferred pursuant to the lease to
    34  own contract:
    35    (1) At least five business days prior to the execution of the lease to
    36  own contract, the manufactured home park owner or  operator,  or  lessor
    37  shall, at his or her expense:
    38    (A)   perform  a  certified  search  through  the  uniform  commercial
    39  code/lien search from the department of state;
    40    (B) perform a records search from the county clerk of the county where
    41  the manufactured or mobile home is located;
    42    (C) perform a records search from the county clerk of the county where
    43  the lessor resides, if different from the county where the  manufactured
    44  or mobile home is located;
    45    (D) if the mobile home is a nineteen hundred ninety-five model year or
    46  newer manufactured home, perform a records search from the department of
    47  motor vehicles; and
    48    (E)  (i)  receive copies of the results of the searches required under
    49  items (A), (B), (C) or (D) of this clause; and
    50    (ii) provide a copy to the lessee, either  by  certified  mail  or  in
    51  person, of each of the searches required under subparagraph one of para-
    52  graph (a) of this subdivision; and
    53    (iii)  discharge  any  lien  or  any security interest encumbering the
    54  manufactured or mobile home, if any exist.
    55    (c) every lease to own contract, whether as a part of a lease, or as a
    56  separate document, shall be in  writing  and  clearly  state  all  terms

        S. 6177--A                          3
     1  governing the transaction. Such terms shall be separately stated and, at
     2  a minimum, include the following:
     3    (i) a description of the home to be leased, including:
     4    (A) the name of the manufacturer of the home;
     5    (B) the serial number of the home; and
     6    (C) the year of manufacture of the home;
     7    (ii) the lot number upon which the home is located in the manufactured
     8  home park;
     9    (iii)  the periodic rent attributable solely to the lot upon which the
    10  manufactured or mobile home is located; such lot rent may  be  increased
    11  over  the  term  of  the  contract,  but  only  in  conformity  with the
    12  provisions of this subdivision;
    13    (iv) the amount of the lease to own payments required to  be  made  in
    14  addition  to the lot rent, including the periodic amount to be paid, the
    15  number of payments required to be made over the term  of  the  agreement
    16  and the total amount of payments to be made;
    17    (v)  the  disclosures required by the federal Consumer Leasing Act, 15
    18  U.S.C.A. § 1667 et. seq., and Regulation M, 12 C.F.R. Part 1013, without
    19  regard to the dollar amount limitations in 12 C.F.R. § 1013.2(e)(1);
    20    (vi) the duration of the lease and, if different, the duration of  the
    21  lease to own option;
    22    (vii) information on whether any fees or public charges are delinquent
    23  or  have  been levied against the manufactured or mobile home, including
    24  any that may have been imposed by or owed to the manufactured home  park
    25  owner;
    26    (viii)  a provision that the manufactured home tenant has the right to
    27  accelerate any lease to own payments;
    28    (ix) whether the manufactured home park owner or operator, or  lessor,
    29  has  received  written  notice from any state or local government entity
    30  requiring any repairs or improvements to be made to the manufactured  or
    31  mobile home that is the subject of the lease to own contract;
    32    (x)  the  following notice: "NOTICE TO THE BUYER: (1) Do not sign this
    33  lease to own contract before you read it or if  it  contains  any  blank
    34  spaces.  (2)  You  are  entitled  to a completely filled in copy of this
    35  lease to own contract when you sign it. (3) Under the law, you have  the
    36  right to pay off in advance the full amount due"; and
    37    (xi)  a  provision  requiring  that in the event the manufactured home
    38  park owner or operator sells or otherwise  transfers  ownership  of  the
    39  manufactured home park to another person or entity, prior to such trans-
    40  fer, the manufactured home park owner or operator shall:
    41    (A) include a provision in the terms of the agreement transferring the
    42  manufactured home park requiring that the purchaser or transferee of the
    43  manufactured  home  park assume all obligations of the manufactured home
    44  park owner or operator with respect to every lease to own contract  then
    45  in effect in the manufactured home park;
    46    (B)  refund  to all manufactured home tenants with currently effective
    47  lease to own contracts, the full amount of all  lease  to  own  payments
    48  made  by the manufactured home tenant over the entire time of his or her
    49  tenancy plus interest at the rate for thirty year fixed  rate  mortgages
    50  as shown on the then current Primary Mortgage Market Survey published by
    51  the  Federal  Home  Loan  Mortgage  Corporation  (also known as "Freddie
    52  Mac"); or
    53    (C) agree to continue to retain ownership  of  the  home  and  receive
    54  lease  to own contract payments until such time as ownership of the home
    55  passes to the manufactured home tenant.

        S. 6177--A                          4
     1    3. Notwithstanding any provision of law to the contrary,  a  lease  to
     2  own contract shall be presumed to be valid if:
     3    (a)  It  complies  with the provisions of the federal Consumer Leasing
     4  Act, 15 U.S.C.A. § 1667 et. seq., and Regulation M, 12 C.F.R. Part 1013,
     5  without  regard  to  the  dollar  amount  limitations  in  12  C.F.R.  §
     6  1013.2(e)(1);
     7    (b) Payments for lot rent are separately stated and not included with-
     8  in the amount of periodic payments for the lease of the home;
     9    (c) It provides that upon payment of the purchase option price and all
    10  periodic lease payments then due, the lessor shall transfer title to the
    11  home to the lessee; and
    12    (d) In the case of lease to own contracts entered into on or after the
    13  effective date of this subdivision, includes the provisions set forth in
    14  paragraph two of this subdivision.
    15    4.  (a)  A  manufactured  home  park owner or operator, or lessor, who
    16  wrongfully terminates the tenancy of a manufactured home tenant  with  a
    17  lease  to  own contract shall refund to the manufactured home tenant the
    18  full amount of all lease to own payments made by the  manufactured  home
    19  tenant  over  the entire time of his or her tenancy plus interest at the
    20  rate specified in section 5-501 of the general obligations law.
    21    (b) For purposes of  this  paragraph,  there  shall  be  a  rebuttable
    22  presumption  that a manufactured home park owner or operator, or lessor,
    23  wrongfully terminated the tenancy if (i)  the  termination  takes  place
    24  within twelve months of the end of the term of the lease to own contract
    25  and (ii) at the time of the termination, the manufactured home tenant is
    26  in  good  standing  as  defined in subparagraph (ii) of paragraph two of
    27  subdivision e of this section.
    28    5. Until such time as ownership of the home passes to the manufactured
    29  home tenant, manufactured homes under a lease to own contract  shall  be
    30  deemed  to be rented homes for purposes of the provisions of subdivision
    31  m of this section. If the lease to own contract is  between  a  manufac-
    32  tured  home tenant and a lessor other than a manufactured home community
    33  owner or operator, the manufactured home shall be deemed to be a  rented
    34  home  for purposes of the provisions of the warranty to habitability set
    35  forth in section two hundred thirty-five-b of this article.
    36    6. No manufactured home park owner or operator shall make any material
    37  misrepresentation, expressly or by implication, in any commercial commu-
    38  nication, regarding any of the  terms  of  the  lease  to  own  contract
    39  including, but not limited to:
    40    (a) The charges for the lease to own contract option;
    41    (b)  The existence, nature, or amount of fees or costs to the manufac-
    42  tured home tenant associated with the lease to own  contract,  including
    43  but not limited to misrepresentations that no fees are charged;
    44    (c) The existence, cost, payment terms, or other terms associated with
    45  any  additional product or feature that is or may be sold in conjunction
    46  with the lease to own contract, including  but  not  limited  to  credit
    47  insurance or credit disability insurance;
    48    (d)  The  terms,  amounts, payments, or other requirements relating to
    49  taxes or insurance associated with the lease to own contract,  including
    50  but not limited to misrepresentations about:
    51    (i) whether separate payment of taxes or insurance is required; or
    52    (ii) the extent to which payment for taxes or insurance is included in
    53  the  loan  payments,  loan amount, or total amount due from the manufac-
    54  tured home tenant;

        S. 6177--A                          5
     1    (e) Any prepayment penalty associated with the lease to own  contract,
     2  including  but  not  limited to misrepresentations concerning the exist-
     3  ence, nature, amount, or terms of such penalty;
     4    (f) The variability of interest, payments, or other terms of the lease
     5  to  own  contract, including but not limited to misrepresentations using
     6  the word "fixed";
     7    (g) Any comparison between:
     8    (i) any rate or payment that will be available for a period less  than
     9  the full length of the lease to own contract; and
    10    (ii) any actual or hypothetical rate or payment;
    11    (h)  The amount of the obligation, or the existence, nature, or amount
    12  of  cash  or  credit  available  to  the  manufactured  home  tenant  in
    13  connection  with the lease to own contract, including but not limited to
    14  misrepresentations that the manufactured  home  tenant  will  receive  a
    15  certain amount of cash or credit as part of the transaction;
    16    (i)  The  existence,  number,  amount,  or  timing  of  any minimum or
    17  required payments, including but not limited to misrepresentations about
    18  any payments or that no payments  are  required  in  the  lease  to  own
    19  contract;
    20    (j) The potential for default under the lease to own contract, includ-
    21  ing  but  not limited to misrepresentations concerning the circumstances
    22  under which the manufactured home tenant could default for nonpayment of
    23  taxes, insurance, or maintenance, or for failure  to  meet  other  obli-
    24  gations;
    25    (k)  The  effectiveness  of  the  lease to own contract in helping the
    26  manufactured home tenant resolve difficulties in paying debts, including
    27  but not limited to misrepresentations that any lease to own contract can
    28  reduce, eliminate, or restructure debt or result in a waiver or forgive-
    29  ness, in whole or in part, of the manufactured  home  tenant's  existing
    30  obligation with any person;
    31    (l)  The  association  of the lease to own contract or any provider of
    32  such contract with any other person or program, including but not limit-
    33  ed to misrepresentations that:
    34    (i) the provider is, or is affiliated with, any governmental entity or
    35  other organization; or
    36    (ii) the product  is  or  relates  to  a  government  benefit,  or  is
    37  endorsed,  sponsored  by,  or  affiliated  with  any government or other
    38  program, including but not  limited  to  through  the  use  of  formats,
    39  symbols,  or  logos that resemble those of such entity, organization, or
    40  program;
    41    (m) The source of any  commercial  communication,  including  but  not
    42  limited to misrepresentations that a commercial communication is made by
    43  or  on  behalf of the manufactured home tenant's current mortgage lender
    44  or servicer;
    45    (n) The right of the manufactured home tenant to reside in the  dwell-
    46  ing that is the subject of the lease to own contract, or the duration of
    47  such right;
    48    (o) The manufactured home tenant's ability or likelihood to obtain any
    49  lease to own contract or term, including but not limited to misrepresen-
    50  tations  concerning whether the manufactured home tenant has been preap-
    51  proved or guaranteed for any such contract or term;
    52    (p) The manufactured home tenant's ability or likelihood to  obtain  a
    53  refinancing  or  modification  of  any  lease  to  own contract or term,
    54  including but not limited to misrepresentations concerning  whether  the
    55  manufactured home tenant has been preapproved or guaranteed for any such
    56  refinancing or modification; and

        S. 6177--A                          6
     1    (q)  The  availability, nature, or substance of counseling services or
     2  any other expert advice offered to the manufactured home tenant  regard-
     3  ing  any lease to own contract or term, including but not limited to the
     4  qualifications of those offering the services or advice.
     5    7.  It is a violation of this subdivision for any person to obtain, or
     6  attempt to obtain, a waiver from any manufactured  home  tenant  of  any
     7  protection  provided  by  or  any  right of the manufactured home tenant
     8  under this subdivision.
     9    8. (a) Manufactured home park owners or operators  offering  lease  to
    10  own  contracts  shall  keep, for a period of twenty-four months from the
    11  last date the manufactured home park owner or operator made  or  dissem-
    12  inated the applicable commercial communication regarding any term of any
    13  lease  to  own  contract, the following evidence of compliance with this
    14  section:
    15    (i) copies of all materially different  commercial  communications  as
    16  well  as  sales  scripts,  training  materials, and marketing materials,
    17  regarding any term of any lease to own contract, that  the  manufactured
    18  home  park  owner  or  operator made or disseminated during the relevant
    19  time period;
    20    (ii) documents describing or evidencing all  lease  to  own  contracts
    21  available  to  manufactured home tenants during the time period in which
    22  the person made or disseminated each commercial communication  regarding
    23  any  term of any lease to own contract, including but not limited to the
    24  names and terms of each such lease to own contract available to manufac-
    25  tured home tenants; and
    26    (iii) documents describing or evidencing all  additional  products  or
    27  services  (such as credit insurance or credit disability insurance) that
    28  are or may be offered or provided with the lease to own contracts avail-
    29  able to manufactured home tenants during the time period  in  which  the
    30  person  made or disseminated each commercial communication regarding any
    31  term of any lease to own contract, including  but  not  limited  to  the
    32  names  and terms of each such additional product or service available to
    33  manufactured home tenants.
    34    (b) Any person who is subject to the provisions  of  this  subdivision
    35  may  keep  the records required by subparagraph (a) of this paragraph in
    36  any legible form, and in the same manner, format, or place as they  keep
    37  such records in the ordinary course of business.
    38    9. Nothing contained in this subdivision shall be deemed to invalidate
    39  a lease to own contract entered into prior to the effective date of this
    40  subdivision.
    41    10.  The  provisions of this subdivision shall apply without regard to
    42  whether the manufactured home that is the subject of the transaction  is
    43  a new home or a resale of a previously-owned home.
    44    § 2. The real property law is amended by adding a new section 233-b to
    45  read as follows:
    46    § 233-b. Manufactured or mobile home lease to own contracts outside of
    47  manufactured  home  parks. 1. Definitions. For purposes of this section,
    48  the following terms shall have the meaning set forth  in  this  subdivi-
    49  sion:
    50    (a)  "Manufactured  home lease to own contract outside of manufactured
    51  home parks" shall mean a lease to own contract as defined  in  paragraph
    52  one of subdivision y of section two hundred thirty-three of this article
    53  where  the  manufactured or mobile home that is the subject of the lease
    54  to own contract is not located in a manufactured home park,  as  defined
    55  in subdivision a of section two hundred thirty-three of this article.

        S. 6177--A                          7
     1    (b) "Lessee" shall mean any person, corporation, association, or other
     2  legal entity who leases a manufactured or mobile home subject to a lease
     3  to own contract.
     4    (c)  "Lessor"  shall  mean any person, corporation, association or any
     5  other legal entity who leases a manufactured or mobile home subject to a
     6  lease to own contract.
     7    (d) "Manufactured home" shall have the same meaning as  set  forth  in
     8  subparagraph four of paragraph a of subdivision y of section two hundred
     9  thirty-three of this article.
    10    (e) "Mobile home" shall have the same meaning as set forth in subpara-
    11  graph  five of paragraph a of subdivision y of section two hundred thir-
    12  ty-three of this article.
    13    2. Requirements for lease to own  contracts  outside  of  manufactured
    14  home parks:
    15    (a) on and after the effective date of this section, no person, corpo-
    16  ration,  association  or any other legal entity shall enter into a lease
    17  to own contract except in accordance with the provisions of this  subdi-
    18  vision;
    19    (b)  on or after the effective date of this section, no person, corpo-
    20  ration, association or other legal entity shall offer  a  lease  to  own
    21  contract  except  in compliance with the provisions of this paragraph to
    22  establish the ownership of the home that is to be  transferred  pursuant
    23  to the lease to own contract:
    24    (1) At least five business days prior to the execution of the lease to
    25  own contract, the lessor shall, at its own expense:
    26    (A)   perform  a  certified  search  through  the  uniform  commercial
    27  code/lien search from the department of state;
    28    (B) perform a records search from the county clerk of the county where
    29  the manufactured or mobile home is located;
    30    (C) perform a records search from the county clerk of the county where
    31  the lessor resides, if different from the county where the  manufactured
    32  or mobile home is located;
    33    (D) if the mobile home is a nineteen hundred ninety-five model year or
    34  newer manufactured home, perform a records search from the department of
    35  motor vehicles; and
    36    (E)  (i)  receive copies of the results of the searches required under
    37  clause (A), (B), (C) or (D) of this subparagraph; and
    38    (ii) provide a copy to the lessee, either  by  certified  mail  or  in
    39  person, of each of the searches required under this subparagraph; and
    40    (iii)  discharge  any  lien  or  any security interest encumbering the
    41  manufactured or mobile home, if any exist.
    42    (c) every lease to own contract, whether as a part of a lease, or as a
    43  separate document, shall be in  writing  and  clearly  state  all  terms
    44  governing the transaction. Such terms shall be separately stated and, at
    45  a minimum, include the following:
    46    (i) a description of the home to be leased, including:
    47    (A) the name of the manufacturer of the home;
    48    (B) the serial number of the home; and
    49    (C) the year of manufacture of the home;
    50    (ii) the address where the home is located;
    51    (iii) if the lessor is also the owner of the land upon which the manu-
    52  factured or mobile home is located, the periodic rent attributable sole-
    53  ly  to  the  lot  upon which the manufactured or mobile home is located;
    54  such lot rent may be increased over the term of the contract,  but  only
    55  upon ninety days notice and not more than once in any year;

        S. 6177--A                          8
     1    (iv)  the  amount  of the lease to own payments required to be made in
     2  addition to the lot rent, if any, including the periodic  amount  to  be
     3  paid,  the  number  of payments required to be made over the term of the
     4  agreement and the total amount of payments to be made;
     5    (v)  the  disclosures required by the federal Consumer Leasing Act, 15
     6  U.S.C.A. § 1667 et.  seq., and Regulation M, 12 C.F.R. Part 1013,  with-
     7  out   regard   to  the  dollar  amount  limitations  in  12  C.F.R.    §
     8  1013.2(e)(1);
     9    (vi) the duration of the lease and, if different, the duration of  the
    10  lease to own option;
    11    (vii) information on whether any fees or public charges are delinquent
    12  or  have  been levied against the manufactured or mobile home, including
    13  any that may have been imposed by or owed to the manufactured home  park
    14  owner;
    15    (viii)  a provision that the manufactured home tenant has the right to
    16  accelerate any lease to own payments;
    17    (ix) whether the manufactured home park owner or operator has received
    18  written notice from any state or local government entity  requiring  any
    19  repairs  or  improvements  to be made to the manufactured or mobile home
    20  that is the subject of the lease to own contract;
    21    (x) the following notice: "NOTICE TO THE BUYER: (1) Do not  sign  this
    22  lease  to  own  contract  before you read it or if it contains any blank
    23  spaces. (2) You are entitled to a completely  filled  in  copy  of  this
    24  lease  to own contract when you sign it. (3) Under the law, you have the
    25  right to pay off in advance the full amount due."; and
    26    (xi) a provision requiring that, in the event the lessor is the  owner
    27  of the land upon which the manufactured home is located, sells or other-
    28  wise transfers ownership of the land upon which the manufactured home is
    29  located to another person or entity other than the lessee, prior to such
    30  transfer, the lessor shall:
    31    (A) include a provision in the terms of the agreement transferring the
    32  land  requiring  that the purchaser or transferee of the land assume all
    33  obligations of the lessor with respect to  the  lessee's  lease  to  own
    34  contract;
    35    (B)  refund  the  full amount of all lease to own payments made by the
    36  lessee over the entire time of his or her tenancy plus interest  at  the
    37  rate  for  thirty year fixed rate mortgages as shown on the then current
    38  Primary Mortgage Market Survey published by the Federal Home Loan  Mort-
    39  gage Corporation (also known as "Freddie Mac"); or
    40    (C)  agree  to  continue  to  retain ownership of the home and receive
    41  lease to own contract payments until such time as ownership of the  home
    42  passes to the lessee.
    43    3.  Notwithstanding  any  provision of law to the contrary, a lease to
    44  own contract shall be presumed to be valid if:
    45    (a) It complies with the provisions of the  federal  Consumer  Leasing
    46  Act, 15 U.S.C.A. § 1667 et. seq., and Regulation M, 12 C.F.R. Part 1013,
    47  without  regard  to  the  dollar  amount  limitations  in  12  C.F.R.  §
    48  1013.2(e)(1);
    49    (b) Payments for lot rent are separately stated and not included with-
    50  in the amount of periodic payments for the lease of the home;
    51    (c) It provides that upon payment of the purchase option price and all
    52  periodic lease payments then due, the lessor shall transfer title to the
    53  home to the lessee; and
    54    (d) In the case of lease to own contracts entered into on or after the
    55  effective date of this subdivision, includes the provisions set forth in
    56  subdivision two of this section.

        S. 6177--A                          9
     1    4. (a) A lessor who is also the landowner of the land upon  which  the
     2  manufactured  home  is located and who wrongfully terminates the tenancy
     3  of a lessee shall refund to the lessee the full amount of all  lease  to
     4  own  payments  made by the manufactured home tenant over the entire time
     5  of  his  or  her  tenancy plus interest at the rate specified in section
     6  5-501 of the general obligations law.
     7    (b) For purposes of this subdivision,  there  shall  be  a  rebuttable
     8  presumption  that a lessor wrongfully terminated the tenancy if: (i) the
     9  termination takes place within twelve months of the end of the  term  of
    10  the  lease  to own contract and (ii) at the time of the termination, the
    11  lessee is not in default in the payment of more than one month's rent to
    12  the lessor, and is not otherwise in violation of the terms of the  lease
    13  to own contract or the terms of the lease governing the lessee's use and
    14  occupancy of the land upon which the manufactured home is located.
    15    5.  Until  such  time  as  ownership of the home passes to the lessee,
    16  manufactured homes under a lease to own contract shall be deemed  to  be
    17  rented  homes  for purposes of the provisions of the warranty to habita-
    18  bility set forth in section two hundred thirty-five-b of this article.
    19    6. No lessor shall make any material misrepresentation,  expressly  or
    20  by  implication,  in  any commercial communication, regarding any of the
    21  terms of the lease to own contract including, but not limited to:
    22    (a) The charges for the lease to own contract option;
    23    (b) The existence, nature, or amount of fees or costs  to  the  lessor
    24  associated  with the lease to own contract, including but not limited to
    25  misrepresentations that no fees are charged;
    26    (c) The existence, cost, payment terms, or other terms associated with
    27  any additional product or feature that is or may be sold in  conjunction
    28  with  the  lease  to  own  contract, including but not limited to credit
    29  insurance or credit disability insurance;
    30    (d) The terms, amounts, payments, or other  requirements  relating  to
    31  taxes  or insurance associated with the lease to own contract, including
    32  but not limited to misrepresentations about:
    33    (i) whether separate payment of taxes or insurance is required; or
    34    (ii) the extent to which payment for taxes or insurance is included in
    35  the loan payments, loan amount, or total amount due from the lessor;
    36    (e) Any prepayment penalty associated with the lease to own  contract,
    37  including  but  not  limited to misrepresentations concerning the exist-
    38  ence, nature, amount, or terms of such penalty;
    39    (f) The variability of interest, payments, or other terms of the lease
    40  to own contract, including but not limited to  misrepresentations  using
    41  the word "fixed";
    42    (g) Any comparison between:
    43    (i)  any rate or payment that will be available for a period less than
    44  the full length of the lease to own contract; and
    45    (ii) any actual or hypothetical rate or payment;
    46    (h) The amount of the obligation, or the existence, nature, or  amount
    47  of  cash  or credit available to the lessee in connection with the lease
    48  to own contract, including but not limited  to  misrepresentations  that
    49  the  lessee  will  receive a certain amount of cash or credit as part of
    50  the transaction;
    51    (i) The existence,  number,  amount,  or  timing  of  any  minimum  or
    52  required payments, including but not limited to misrepresentations about
    53  any  payments  or  that  no  payments  are  required in the lease to own
    54  contract;
    55    (j) The potential for default under the lease to own contract, includ-
    56  ing but not limited to misrepresentations concerning  the  circumstances

        S. 6177--A                         10
     1  under which the lessee could default for nonpayment of taxes, insurance,
     2  or maintenance, or for failure to meet other obligations;
     3    (k)  The  effectiveness  of  the  lease to own contract in helping the
     4  lessee resolve difficulties in paying debts, including but  not  limited
     5  to  misrepresentations that any lease to own contract can reduce, elimi-
     6  nate, or restructure debt or result in a waiver or forgiveness, in whole
     7  or in part, of the lessee's existing obligation with any person;
     8    (l) The association of the lease to own contract or  any  provider  of
     9  such contract with any other person or program, including but not limit-
    10  ed to misrepresentations that:
    11    (i) the provider is, or is affiliated with, any governmental entity or
    12  other organization; or
    13    (ii)  the  product  is  or  relates  to  a  government  benefit, or is
    14  endorsed, sponsored by, or  affiliated  with  any  government  or  other
    15  program,  including  but  not  limited  to  through  the use of formats,
    16  symbols, or logos that resemble those of such entity,  organization,  or
    17  program;
    18    (m)  The  source  of  any  commercial communication, including but not
    19  limited to misrepresentations that a commercial communication is made by
    20  or on behalf of the lessee's current mortgage lender or servicer;
    21    (n) The right of the lessee to reside in  the  dwelling  that  is  the
    22  subject of the lease to own contract, or the duration of such right;
    23    (o)  The  lessee's  ability  or  likelihood to obtain any lease to own
    24  contract or  term,  including  but  not  limited  to  misrepresentations
    25  concerning whether the lessee has been preapproved or guaranteed for any
    26  such contract or term;
    27    (p)  The  lessee's  ability  or  likelihood to obtain a refinancing or
    28  modification of any lease to own contract or  term,  including  but  not
    29  limited  to  misrepresentations  concerning  whether the lessee has been
    30  preapproved or guaranteed for any such refinancing or modification; and
    31    (q) The availability, nature, or substance of counseling  services  or
    32  any other expert advice offered to the lessee regarding any lease to own
    33  contract  or  term,  including  but not limited to the qualifications of
    34  those offering the services or advice.
    35    7. It is a violation of this section for  any  person  to  obtain,  or
    36  attempt  to  obtain, a waiver from any lessee of any protection provided
    37  by or any right of the lessee under this section.
    38    8. (a) Lessors offering lease to own contracts shall keep, for a peri-
    39  od of twenty-four months from the last date the lessor made  or  dissem-
    40  inated the applicable commercial communication regarding any term of any
    41  lease  to  own  contract, the following evidence of compliance with this
    42  section:
    43    (i) copies of all materially different  commercial  communications  as
    44  well  as  sales  scripts,  training  materials, and marketing materials,
    45  regarding any term of any lease to own contract, that the lessor made or
    46  disseminated during the relevant time period;
    47    (ii) documents describing or evidencing all  lease  to  own  contracts
    48  available  to lessees during the time period in which the person made or
    49  disseminated each commercial communication regarding  any  term  of  any
    50  lease  to own contract, including but not limited to the names and terms
    51  of each such lease to own contract available to lessees; and
    52    (iii) documents describing or evidencing all  additional  products  or
    53  services  (such as credit insurance or credit disability insurance) that
    54  are or may be offered or provided with the lease to own contracts avail-
    55  able to lessees during the time period  in  which  the  person  made  or
    56  disseminated  each  commercial  communication  regarding any term of any

        S. 6177--A                         11
     1  lease to own contract, including but not limited to the names and  terms
     2  of each such additional product or service available to lessees.
     3    (b)  Any  person  who is subject to the provisions of this subdivision
     4  may keep the records required by subparagraph (a) of this subdivision in
     5  any legible form, and in the same manner, format, or place as they  keep
     6  such records in the ordinary course of business.
     7    9.  Nothing  contained in this section shall be deemed to invalidate a
     8  lease to own contract entered into prior to the effective date  of  this
     9  section.
    10    10.  The  provisions  of  this  section  shall apply without regard to
    11  whether the manufactured home that is the subject of the transaction  is
    12  a new home or a resale of a previously-owned home.
    13    11. No lendor shall:
    14    (a) place or hold any mortgage on any manufactured or mobile home sold
    15  under a lease to own contract; or
    16    (b) cause any insurance coverage on the manufactured or mobile home to
    17  lapse or end for the duration of the lease owned contract.
    18    12. Except as otherwise provided, failure of the lessor to comply with
    19  this section shall give the lessee the unconditional right to cancel the
    20  lease  with the option to purchase contract and receive immediate refund
    21  of all payments and deposits made on account of or in  contemplation  of
    22  the lease with the option to purchase contract.
    23    § 3. This act shall take effect on the one hundred eightieth day after
    24  it shall have become a law.
feedback